Libertarianism and Circumcision

Document Type: Debate

Authors

Joseph A. Butt, S.J. College of Business, Loyola University, New Orleans, USA

Abstract

Despite the millenniums-old tradition in Abrahamic circles of removing the foreskin of a penis at birth, the involuntary and aggressive practice of circumcision must not be made an exception to the natural, negative right to self-ownership—a birthright which should prevent a parent from physically harming a child from the moment of birth going forward. This paper will present a natural rights argument against the practice of male child circumcision, while also looking into some of the potential physical and psychological consequences of the practice. It will compare the practice with that of female circumcision, which is banned in developed nations but still practiced in the third world, as well as other forms of aggressive action, some once-prevalent, while disputing arguments made for parental ownership of the child, religious expression, cultural tradition, cleanliness, cosmetics, and conformity.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. Darby RJ. Medical history and medical practice: persistent myths about the foreskin. Med J Aust 2003; 178: 178–9.
  2. Darby RJ. The riddle of the sands: circumcision, history, and myth. N Z Med J 2005; 118: U1564.
  3. Gollaher D. Circumcision: a history of the world’s most controversial surgery. New York: Basic Books; 2000.
  4. Marck J. Aspects of male circumcision in sub-equatorial African culture history. Health Transit Review 1997; 7: 337–60.
  5. West JA. The traveler’s key to ancient Egypt: a guide to the sacred places of ancient Egypt. Wheaton: Theosophical Publishing House; 1995. p. 187.
  6. The Circumcision Information and Resource Pages [homepage on the Internet]. [updated 2011 August 28]. History of Circumcision. Available from: http://www.cirp.org/library/history
  7. Silverman EK. The Cut of Wholeness: Psychoanalytic Interpretations of Biblical Circumcision. In: Mark EW, editor.  The Covenant of Circumcision. Hanover and London: Brandeis University Press; 2003. pp. 43–57.
  8. Glick NS. Zipporah and the Bridegroom of Blood: Searching for the Antecedents of Jewish Circumcision. In: Denniston GC,  Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 37–48.
  9. Narvaez D. Circumcision: Social, Sexual, Psychological Realities. Psychology Today [serial on the Internet]. 2011 September 18. Available from:  http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/moral-landscapes/201109/circumcision-social-sexual-psychological-realities
  10. Locke J. An Essay Concerning the True Origin, Extent and End of Civil Government. In: Barker E, editor. Social Contract. New York: Oxford University Press; 1948.
  11. Locke J. Second Treatise of Civil Government. Chicago: Henry Regnery; 1955.
  12. Barnett RE. The Intersection of Natural Rights and Positive Constitutional Law. Connecticut Law Review 1993; 25: 853–68.
  13. Barnett RE. Getting Normative, the Role of Natural Rights in Constitutional Adjudication. Constitutional Commentary 1995; 12: 93–122. doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199243006.003.0008
  14. Blackman  RJ. There is There There: Defending the Defenseless with Procedural Natural Law. Arizona Law Review 1995; 37: 285–353.
  15. Flew A. Could there be Universal Natural Rights? The Journal of Libertarian Studies 1982; 6: 277–88.
  16. Machan T. Against nonlibertarian natural rights. The Journal of Libertarian Studies 1978; 2: 233–38.
  17. Osterfeld D. The Natural Rights Debate: A Comment on a Reply. The Journal of Libertarian Studies 1983; 2: 101–13.
  18. Rothbard MN. Introduction to Natural Law. Mises Daily [serial on the Internet]. 2007. Available from: https://mises.org/daily/2426
  19. Van Dun F. Human dignity: reason or desire? Journal of Libertarian Studies 2001;15: 1–28.
  20. Kinsella SN. 2006. How we come to own ourselves. Mises Daily [serial on the Internet].  2006 September 7. Available from: http://www.mises.org/story/2291
  21. Forde S. John Locke and the Natural Law and Natural Rights Tradition. Natural Law, Natural Rights, and American Constitutionalism [serial on the Internet]. 2012. Available from: http://www.nlnrac.org/earlymodern/locke
  22. Block WE. Libertarianism, Positive Obligations and Property Abandonment: Children’s Rights. International Journal of Social Economics 2004; 31: 275–86.  doi: 10.1108/03068290410518256
  23. Block WE. A libertarian perspective on the stem cell debate: compromising the uncompromisible. J Med Philos 2010; 35: 429–48. doi: 10.1093/jmp/jhq033
  24. Block WE. Terri Schiavo: A Libertarian Analysis. Journal of Libertarian Studies 2011; 22: 527–36.
  25. Block WE, Whitehead R. Compromising the Uncompromisable: A Private Property Rights Approach to Resolving the Abortion Controversy. Appalachian Law Review 2005; 4: 1–45.
  26. Rights. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2011 July 2. Available from: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rights
  27. Lannon CM, Bailey AND, Fleischman AR, Kaplan GW,  Shoemaker CT, Swanson JT, et al. American Academy of Pediatrics: Circumcision Policy Statement. Pediatrics 1999; 103: 686–93. doi: 10.1542/peds.103.3.686
  28. Kukathas C. Two Constructions of Libertarianism [internet]. 2001. Available from:  http://mises.org/journals/scholar/libertarian.pdf
  29. Rothbard MN. The Ethics of Liberty. New York and London: New York University Press; 1998.
  30. Universal Declaration of Human Rights [internet]. 1948. The United Nations. Available from: http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr
  31. Convention On the Rights of the Child. 1989. The United Nations. Available from:   http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/pdf/crc.pdf
  32. Shah A. Rights of the Child. Global Issues [serial on the Internet]. 2003 September 27. Available from: http://www.globalissues.org/article/152/rights-of-the-child
  33. Reynaert D, Bouverne-de-Bie M, Vandevelde S. A review of children’s rights literature since the adoption of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Childhood 2009; 16: 518–34. doi: 10.1177/0907568209344270
  34. Stedman’s Medical Dictionary. Baltimore: William & Wilkins Publishers; 1990. p. 1009.
  35. Glick LB. Marked in Your Flesh. New York: Oxford University Press; 2005
  36. Narvaez D. Myths about Circumcision You Likely Believe. Psychology Today [serial on the Internet]. 2011 September 11. Available from: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/moral-landscapes/201109/myths-about-circumcision-you-likely-believe
  37. 37.   Denniston GC. An Epidemic of Circumcision. National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers [serial on the Internet]. 1994. Available from: http://www.nocirc.org/symposia/third/denniston3.html
  38. Narvaez D. Circumcision Ethics and Economics. Psychology Today [serial on the Internet]. 2011 September 25. Available from: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/moral-landscapes/201109/circumcision-ethics-and-economics
  39. Atendido MCM. The 2012 AAP Policy Statement: Skinning the New Policy on Circumcision [internet]. 2013. Available from: http://www.law.uh.edu/healthlaw/perspectives/2013/Atendio_The 202012 20AAP 20Policy 20Statement_Skinning 20the 20New 20Policy 20on 20Circumcision.pdf
  40. BMA Medical Ethics Committee. The Law & Ethics of Male Circumcision – Guidance For Doctors [internet]. 2006 June 15. Available from: http://www.cirp.org/library/statements/bma2003
  41. Denniston GC. Human Rights Advances in the United States. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 189–202.
  42. Craig A, Bollinger D. Of Waste and Want: A Nationwide Survey of Medicaid Funding for Medically Unnecessary, Non-Therapeutic Circumcision. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 233–46.
  43. Geisheker JV. Toward Regulation of Non-Therapeutic Genital Surgeries Upon Minors: A Preliminary Legal Strategy. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 203–18.
  44. Evans S. German Circumcision Ban: Is It a Parent’s Right to Choose. BBC News [serial on the internet]. 2012 July 12. Available from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-18793842
  45. Boyle GJ, Svoboda JS, Price CP, Turner JN. Circumcision of Healthy Boys: Criminal Assault? J Law Med 2000; 7: 301–10.
  46. Whitehorn J, Ayonrinde O, Maingay S. Female Genital Mutilation: Cultural and Psychological Implications. Sex Relation Ther 2002; 17: 161–70. doi: 10.1080/14681990220121275
  47. McKinnon C. Toleration. London and New York: Routledge; 2006.
  48. 48.   Svoboda JS. Genital Integrity and Gender Equity. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 149–64.
  49. Erez S, Tabory E. Circumscribed Circumcision: The Motivations and Identities of Israeli Parents Who Choose Not to Circumcise Their Sons. In: Mark EW, editor. The Covenant of Circumcision. Hanover and London: Brandeis University Press; 2003. p. 161–76.
  50. Abusharaf RM. Virtuous Cuts: Female Genital Circumcision in an African Ontology. In: Scott JW, Keates D, editors. Going Public: Feminism and the Shifting Boundaries of the Private Sphere. Urbana and Champaign: University of Illinois Press; 2004. p. 201–24.
  51. Young H. Circumcision as a Memeplex. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 1–16.
  52. Geisheker JV. What Is the Greatest Danger for an Uncircumcised Boy? Psychology Today [serial on the internet]. 2011 October 23. Available from: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/moral-landscapes/201110/what-is-the-greatest-danger-uncircumcised-boy
  53. Llewellyn DJ. Strategies for Litigation. In: Denniston GC, Gallo PG, Hodges FM, Milos MF, Viviani F, editors. Bodily Integrity and the Politics of Circumcision. New York: Springer; 2006. p. 219–32.
  54. Narvaez D. More Circumcision Myths You May Believe: Hygiene and STDs. Psychology Today [serial on the internet]. 2011 September 13. Available from: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/moral-landscapes/201109/more-circumcision-myths-you-may-believe-hygiene-and-stds.
  55. Dewan PA, Tieu HC, Chieng BS. Phimosis: is circumcision necessary. J Paediatr Child Health 1996; 32: 285–9. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1754.1996.tb02554.x
  56. McGregor TB, Pike JG, Leonard MP. Pathologic and physiologic phimosis: approach to the phimotic foreskin. Can Fam Physician 2007; 53: 445–8.
  57. Steadman B, Ellsworth P. To circ or not to circ: indications, risks, and alternatives to circumcision in the pediatric population with phimosis. Urol Nurs 2006; 26: 181–94.
  58. Learman LA. Neonatal Circumcision: A Dispassionate Analysis. Clin Obstet Gynecol 1999; 42: 849–59. doi: 10.1097/00003081-199912000-00011
  59. World Health Organization and Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AID. Male Circumcision: Global Trends and Determinants of Prevalence, Safety and Acceptability [internet]. 2007. Available from: http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2007/9789241596169_eng.pdf
  60. American Academy of Family Physicians.Circumcision: Position Paper on Neonatal Circumcision. 2002. Available from: http://www.cirp.org/library/statements/aafp2002/
  61. Auvert B, Taljaard D, Lagarde E, Sobngwi-Tambekou J, Sitta R, Puren A. Randomized, Controlled Intervention Trial of Male Circumcision for Reduction of HIV Infection risk: The ANRS 1265 Trial. PLoS Med 2005; 2: e298. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.0020298
  62. Gray R, Kigozi G, Serwadda D, Makumbi F, Watya S, Nalugoda F, et al. Male circumcision for HIV prevention in men in Rakai, Uganda: a randomised trial. Lancet 2007; 369: 657–66. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(07)60313-4
  63. Bailey RC, Moses S, Parker CB, Agot K, Maclean I, Krieger JN, et al. Male circumcision for HIV prevention in young men in Kisumu, Kenya: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 2007; 369: 643–56. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(07)60312-2
  64. The World Factbook. Central Intelligence Agency [internet]. 2011. Available from: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook
  65. Williams BG, Lloyd-Smith JO, Gouws E, Hankins C, Getz WM, Hargrove J, et al. The potential impact of male circumcision on HIV in Sub-Saharan Africa. PLoS Med 2006; 3: e262.  doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.0030262
  66. Laumann EO, Masi CM, Zuckerman EW. Circumcision in the United States: prevalence, prophylactic effects, and sexual practice. JAMA 1997; 277: 1052–7. doi: 10.1001/jama.277.13.1052
  67. McAllister RG, Travis JW, Bollinger D, Rutiser C, Veeraraghavan Sundar. The Cost to Circumcise Africa. International Journal of Men’s Health 2008; 7: 307–16. doi: 10.3149/jmh.0703.307
  68. Van Howe RS. A Cost-Utility Analysis of Neonatal Circumcision. Med Decis Making 2004; 24: 584–601. doi: 10.1177/0272989x04271039
  69. Boyle GJ, Goldman R, Svoboda JS, Fernandez E. 1 May 2002. Male Circumcision: Pain Trauma and Psychosexual Sequelae. J Health Psychol 2002; 7: 329–43. doi: 10.1177/1359105302007003225
  70. Hammond T. A preliminary poll of men circumcised in infancy or childhood. BJU Int 1999; 83: 85–92. doi: 10.1046/j.1464-410x.1999.0830s1085.x
  71. Frisch M, Lindholm M, Grønbæk M. Male circumcision and sexual function in men and women: a survey-based, cross-sectional study in Denmark. Int J Epidemiol  2011; 40: 1367–81. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyr104
  72. Aydur E, Gungor S, Ceyhan ST, Taiimaz L, Baser I. Effects of Childhood Circumcision Age on Adult Male Sexual Functions. Int J Impot Res 2007; 19: 424–31. doi: 10.1038/sj.ijir.3901545
  73. Goldman R. The Psychological Impact of Circumcision. BJU Int 1999; 83: 93–102. doi: 10.1046/j.1464-410x.1999.0830s1093.x
  74. Ramos S, Boyle GJ. Ritual and Medical Circumcision Among Filipino Boys: Evidence of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder. Humanities & Social Sciences Papers 2000. Available from: http://epublications.bond.edu.au/hss_pubs/114/
  75. Zhang X, Shinde S, Kilmarx PH, Chen RT, Cox S, Warner L, et al. Trends in In-Hospital Newborn Male Circumcision, United States, 1999-2010. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2011. Available from: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6034a4.htm
  76. Kozak LJ, Lees KA, DeFrances CJ. National Hospital Discharge Survey: 2003 annual summary with detailed diagnosis and procedure data. Vital Health Statistics, 2006; 13. Available from: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_13/sr13_160.pdf
  77. Friedman M. Free to Choose. New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich; 1980.