Complex Leadership in Healthcare: A Scoping Review

Document Type: Review Article

Authors

1 National School of Public Health, Rabat, Morocco

2 Department of Public Health, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerpen, Belgium

3 Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium.

Abstract

Background
Nowadays, health systems are generally acknowledged to be complex social systems. Consequently, scholars, academics, practitioners, and policy-makers are exploring how to adopt a complexity perspective in health policy and system research. While leadership and complexity has been studied extensively outside health, the implications of complexity theories for the study of leadership in healthcare have received limited attention. We carried out a scoping review of complex leadership (CL) in healthcare to investigate how CL in healthcare has been defined, theorised and conceptualised and to explore how ‘CL’ has been applied in healthcare settings.
 
Methods
We followed the methodological steps proposed by (Arksey and O’Malley, 2005): (1) specifying the research question, (2) identifying relevant studies, (3) study selection, (4) charting the data, (5) collating and summarizing the findings, and (6) reporting the results. We searched using Medline, Psychinfo, Wiley online library, and Google Scholar. Our inclusion criteria were: publication type (peer reviewed articles, theses, and book chapters); phenomenon of interest: complex leadership; context: healthcare and period of publication: between 2000 and 2016.
 
Results
Our search and selection resulted in 37 papers (16 conceptual papers, 14 empirical studies and 7 advocacy papers). We note that empirical studies on CL are few and almost all research reported by these papers was carried out in the North (mainly in USA and UK). We found that there is some variation in definitions of CL. Furthermore, the research papers adopt mostly an explorative or explanatory approach and do not focus on assessing effectiveness of CL approaches. Finally, we found that the majority of researchers seem to adhere to the mathematical complexity perspective.
 
Conclusion
Complexity concepts derived from natural sciences may not automatically fit management of health services. Further research into how social complexity theories may offer researchers useful grounds to empirically test CL theories in health settings is warranted. Specific attention should be paid to the multi-layered nature of leadership.

Highlights

Supplementary File 1 (Download)

Supplementary File 2 (Download)

Supplementary File 3 (Download)

Supplementary File 4 (Download)

Supplementary File 5 (Download)

Supplementary File 6 (Download)

Keywords

Main Subjects


"Watch the Video Summary"

 

  1. WHO-AHPSR. Open Mindsets: Participatory Leadership for Health. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, Alliance for Health Policy and System Research; 2016.
  2. WHO-AHPSR. Investing in Knowledge for resilient health systems. Geneva: World Health Organization, Alliance for Health Policy and System Research; 2016.
  3. WHO-AHPSR. Changing mindsets Strategy on health Policy and Systems research. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2012.
  4. Handy C. Understanding Organizations. UK: Penguin; 2007.
  5. Fiedler FE. A Contingency Model of Leadership Effectiveness1. Adv Exp Soc Psychol. Vol 1. Elsevier; 1964:149-190.
  6. Parry K, Bryman A. Leadership in Organizations. In: Clegg S, Hardy C, Nord W, eds. Handbook of Organization Studies. London: Sage; 2006.
  7. Hersey P, Blanchard KH. The management of change: I. Change and the use of power. Train Dev J. 1972;26(1):6-10.
  8. Burns JM. Leadership. New York: Harper & Row; 1978.
  9. Bass BM. Leadership and Performance. New York: Free Press; 1985.
  10. Hazy J. Measuring leadership effectiveness in complex socio-technical systems. Emergence: Complexity & Organization. 2006;8(3):58-77.
  11. Peters TJ, Waterman RH Jr. In search of excellence: Lessons from America's best-run companies. London: Profile Books; 1982.
  12. Padilla A, Hogan R, Kaiser RB. The toxic triangle: Destructive leaders, susceptible followers, and conducive environments. Leadersh Q. 2007;18(3):176-194. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2007.03.001
  13. Einarsen S, Aasland MS, Skogstad A. Destructive leadership behaviour: A definition and conceptual model. Leadersh Q. 2007;18(3):207-216. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2007.03.002
  14. Begun JW, Thygeson M. Complexity and healthcare: Tools for Engagement. In: Mick SS, Shay PD, eds. Advances in Health Care Organization Theory. San Francisco, USA: Jossey-Bass; 2014.
  15. Plowman DA, Duchon D. Dispelling the myths about leadership: From cybernetics to emergence. Complexity leadership Part. 2008;1:129-153.
  16. Uhl-Bien M, Marion R, McKelvey B. Complexity leadership theory: shifting leadership from the industrial age to the knowledge era. Leadership, Gender, and Organization. Springer; 2011:109-138.
  17. Marion R, Uhl-Bien M. Leadership in complex organizations. Leadersh Q. 2001;12(4):389-418. doi:10.1016/S1048-9843(01)00092-3
  18. Thompson DS, Fazio X, Kustra E, Patrick L, Stanley D. Scoping review of complexity theory in health services research. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016;16:87. doi:10.1186/s12913-016-1343-4
  19. Cunha CJCdA, Gunther HF, Gramkow FB, Casses Zoucas A. Leadership and Complexity: A Bibliometric Study. Academy of Taiwan Business Management Review. 2015;4(12):578-590.
  20. Plsek PE, Wilson T. Complexity, leadership, and management in healthcare organisations. BMJ. 2001;323(7315):746-749. doi:10.1136/bmj.323.7315.746
  21. Kernick D. Complexity and healthcare organization: a view from the street. United Kingdom: Radcliffe Publishing; 2004.
  22. Arksey H, O'Malley L. Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol. 2005;8(1):19-32. doi:10.1080/1364557032000119616
  23. Anderson S, Allen P, Peckham S, Goodwin N. Asking the right questions: scoping studies in the commissioning of research on the organisation and delivery of health services. Health Res Policy Syst. 2008;6:7. doi:10.1186/1478-4505-6-7
  24. Daudt HM, van Mossel C, Scott SJ. Enhancing the scoping study methodology: a large, inter-professional team's experience with Arksey and O'Malley's framework. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2013;13:48. doi:10.1186/1471-2288-13-48
  25. Levac D, Colquhoun H, O'Brien KK. Scoping studies: advancing the methodology. Implement Sci. 2010;5:69. doi:10.1186/1748-5908-5-69
  26. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 2009;6(7):e1000097. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097
  27. Cooper H, Hedges LV, Valentine JC. The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis. 2nd ed. New York: Russel Sage Foundation; 2009.
  28. Orwin RG, Vevea JL. Evaluating Coding Decisions. In: Cooper H, Hedges LV, Valentine JC, eds. The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation; 2009:177-203.
  29. Anderson RA, McDaniel RR Jr. Managing health care organizations: where professionalism meets complexity science. Health Care Manage Rev. 2000;25(1):83-92. doi:10.1097/00004010-200001000-00010
  30. Burns JP. Complexity science and leadership in healthcare. J Nurs Adm. 2001;31(10):474-482.
  31. Plsek PE, Wilson T. Complexity, leadership, and management in healthcare organisations. BMJ. 2001;323(7315):746-749.
  32. Minas H. Leadership for change in complex systems. Australas Psychiatry. 2005;13(1):33-39. doi:10.1080/j.1440-1665.2004.02147.x
  33. Penprase B, Norris D. What nurse leaders should know about complex adaptive systems theory. Nurs Leadersh Forum. 2005;9(3):127-132.
  34. Forbes-Thompson S, Leiker T, Bleich MR. High-performing and low-performing nursing homes: a view from complexity science. Health Care Manage Rev. 2007;32(4):341-351. doi:10.1097/01.HMR.0000296789.39128.f6
  35. Ford R. Complex leadership competency in health care: towards framing a theory of practice. Health Serv Manage Res. 2009;22(3):101-114. doi:10.1258/hsmr.2008.008016
  36. Chadwick MM. Creating order out of chaos: a leadership approach. Aorn J. 2010;91(1):154-170. doi:10.1016/j.aorn.2009.06.029
  37. Davidson SJ. Complex responsive processes: a new lens for leadership in twenty-first-century health care. Nurs Forum. 2010;45(2):108-117. doi:10.1111/j.1744-6198.2010.00171.x
  38. Gonnering RS. Future demands complex leadership. Physician Exec. 2010;36(2):6-10.
  39. Hanson WR, Ford R. Complexity leadership in healthcare: Leader network awareness. Procedia Soc Behav Sci. 2010;2(4):6587-6596. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2010.04.069
  40. Martin CM. Making sense of polarities in health organizations for policy and leadership. J Eval Clin Pract. 2010;16(5):990-993. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2753.2010.01529.x
  41. Ott AMN. Through the looking glass of complexity leadership theory: A biomedical case study in radical innovation leadership [dissertation]. Washington, DC: The Graduate School of Education and Human Development of George Washington University; 2010.
  42. Price J. Complexity, Leadership and Management in Primary Care. Primary Care. 2011.
  43. Bailey DE Jr, Docherty SL, Adams JA, et al. Studying the clinical encounter with the Adaptive Leadership framework. J Healthc Leadersh. 2012;2012(4). doi:10.2147/jhl.s32686
  44. McCarthy I. The complexity of leadership and organisations [thesis]. Birmingham: Aston University; 2012.
  45. Sturmberg JP, Martin CM. Leadership and transitions: maintaining the science in complexity and complex systems. J Eval Clin Pract. 2012;18(1):186-189. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2753.2011.01789.x
  46. Weberg D. Complexity leadership: a healthcare imperative. Nurs Forum. 2012;47(4):268-277. doi:10.1111/j.1744-6198.2012.00276.x
  47. Corazzini KN, Anderson RA, Day L, McConnell ES, Mueller C, McKinney SH. When a situation is "not black or white": Using adaptive leadership to address complex challenges in nursing home care. Director. 2013;21(4):34-37.
  48. Lindstrom RR. Leadership needs to shift in the health system: three emerging perspectives to inform our way forward. Healthc Pap. 2013;13(1):48-54; discussion 78-82.
  49. Weberg DR. Complexity leadership theory and innovation: A new framework for innovation leadership [dissertation]. Arizona: Arizona State University; 2013.
  50. Cohn J. Leading healthcare in complexity. Nurs Leadersh (Tor Ont). 2014;27(4):52-64.  
  51. Gilson L, Elloker S, Olckers P, Lehmann U. Advancing the application of systems thinking in health: South African examples of a leadership of sensemaking for primary health care. Health Res Policy Syst. 2014;12:30. doi:10.1186/1478-4505-12-30
  52. Prashanth NS, Marchal B, Devadasan N, Kegels G, Criel B. Advancing the application of systems thinking in health: a realist evaluation of a capacity building programme for district managers in Tumkur, India. Health Res Policy Syst. 2014;12:42. doi:10.1186/1478-4505-12-42
  53. Viitala R. Leadership in transformation: a longitudinal study in a nursing organization. J Health Organ Manag. 2014;28(5):602-618. doi:10.1108/jhom-02-2014-0032
  54. Anderson RA, Bailey DE Jr, Wu B, et al. Adaptive leadership framework for chronic illness: framing a research agenda for transforming care delivery. ANS Adv Nurs Sci. 2015;38(2):83-95. doi:10.1097/ans.0000000000000063
  55. Crowell DM. Complexity Leadership: Nursing's Role in Health Care Delivery. F.A. Davis; 2015.
  56. Grady CM. Exploring Physician Leadership Development in Health-Care Organizations Through the Lens of Complexity Science [dissertation]. Athabasca, Alberta: Faculty of Business; 2015.
  57. Kwamie A, Agyepong IA, van Dijk H. What Governs District Manager Decision Making? A Case Study of Complex Leadership in Dangme West District, Ghana. Health Syst Reform. 2015;1(2):167-177. doi:10.1080/23288604.2015.1032475
  58. Linderman A, Pesut D, Disch J. Sense Making and Knowledge Transfer: Capturing the Knowledge and Wisdom of Nursing Leaders. J Prof Nurs. 2015;31(4):290-297. doi:10.1016/j.profnurs.2015.02.004
  59. McKimm J, Till A. Clinical leadership effectiveness, change and complexity. Br J Hosp Med (Lond). 2015;76(4):239-243. doi:10.12968/hmed.2015.76.4.239
  60. Porter-O'Grady T. Confluence and convergence: team effectiveness in complex systems. Nurs Adm Q. 2015;39(1):78-83. doi:10.1097/naq.0000000000000035
  61. Prescott D, Rowe M. Leadership in systems, organizations and cultures. Br J Hosp Med (Lond). 2015;76(2):101-104. doi:10.12968/hmed.2015.76.2.101
  62. Arena MJ, Uhl-Bien M. Complexity Leadership Theory: Shifting from Human Capital to Social Capital. People and Strategy; 2016.
  63. Aubyn H. The Influence of Leadership Paradigms and Styles on Pharmaceutical Innovation. In: Schuhmacher A, Hinder M, Gassmann O, eds. Value Creation in the Pharmaceutical Industry. Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA; 2016:416-447.
  64. Miller CP. Mental health leadership and complexity. International Journal of Complexity in Leadership and Management. 2016;3(1-2):154-161. doi:10.1504/ijclm.2016.079536
  65. Weberg D. Innovation Leadership Behaviors: Starting the Complexity Journey. In: Leadership for Evidence-Based Innovation in Nursing and Health Professions. Jones & Bartlett Learning; 2016.
  66. Uhl-Bien M, Marion R, McKelvey B. Complexity Leadership Theory: Shifting leadership from the industrial age to the knowledge era. Leadersh Q. 2007;18(4):298-318. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2007.04.002
  67. Uhl-Bien M, Marion R. Complexity Leadership Part 1. Charlottes North Carolina: Information Age Publishing; 2008.
  68. Plsek PE, Greenhalgh T. Complexity science: The challenge of complexity in health care. BMJ. 2001;323(7313):625-628.
  69. Zimmerman B, Lindberg C, Plsek PE. Edgeware: Insights from complexity ideas for health care leaders. Irving, TX: VHA. 1998.
  70. Weick KE, Roberts KH. Collective Mind in Organizations: Heedful Interrelating on Flight Decks. Adm Sci Q. 1993;38(3):357-381. doi:10.2307/2393372
  71. Stacey RD. Managing the unknowable: Strategic boundaries between order and chaos in organizations. John Wiley & Sons; 1992.
  72. Dooley KJ. A Complex Adaptive Systems Model of Organization Change. Nonlinear Dynamics Psychol Life Sci. 1997;1(1):69-97. doi:10.1023/a:1022375910940
  73. Anderson RA, Issel LM, McDaniel RR Jr. Nursing homes as complex adaptive systems: relationship between management practice and resident outcomes. Nurs Res. 2003;52(1):12-21.
  74. Lichtenstein BB, Uhl-Bien M, Marion R, Seers A, Orton JD, Schreiber C. Complexity leadership theory: An interactive perspective on leading in complex adaptive systems. Emergence: Complexity and Organization. 2006;8(4):2-12.
  75. Kauffman S, Macready W. Technological evolution and adaptive organizations: Ideas from biology may find applications in economics. Complexity. 1995;1(2):26-43. doi:10.1002/cplx.6130010208
  76. Thygeson M, Morrissey L, Ulstad V. Adaptive leadership and the practice of medicine: a complexity-based approach to reframing the doctor-patient relationship. J Eval Clin Pract. 2010;16(5):1009-1015. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2753.2010.01533.x
  77. Snowden D, Standbridge P. The landscape of management: Creating the context for understanding social complexity. Emergence: Complexity and Organization. 2004;6(1-2):140-148.
  78. Bhaskar R. A Realist Theory of Science. London: Routledge (Taylor & Francis Group); 2008.
  79. Weick KE. The Collapse of Sensemaking in Organizations: The Mann Gulch Disaster. Adm Sci Q. 1993;38(4):628-652. doi:10.2307/2393339
  80. Weick KE, Sutcliffe KM. Managing the Unexpected: Resilient Performance in an Age of Uncertanity. Jossey-Bass; 2007.
  81. Gibson R. Rethinking the Future: Rethinking Business Principles, Competition, Control and Complexity, Leadership, Markets and the World. Nicholas Brealey Publishing; 2011.
  82. Polack J, Adler D, Sankaran S. Mapping the field of Complexity Theory : A computational approach to understanding changes in the field. Emergence: Complexity and Organization. 2014;16(2):74-92.
  83. Rusoja E, Haynie D, Sievers J, et al. Thinking about complexity in health: a systematic review of the key systems thinking and complexity ideas in health. J Eval Clin Pract. 2018;24(3):600-606. doi:10.1111/jep.12856
  84. Marion R. Complexity theory for organizations and organizational leadership. In: Bien MU, Marion R, eds. Complexity Leadership, Part 1. Charlotte North Carolina: Information Age Publishing; 2008.
  85. Burnes B. Complexity theories and organizational change. International Journal of Management Reviews. 2005;7(2):73-90. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2370.2005.00107.x
  86. McKelvey B. Complexity Theory in Organization Science: Seizing the Promise or Becoming a Fad? Emergence. 1999;1(1):5-32. doi:10.1207/s15327000em0101_2
  87. Sturmberg JP, Martin CM, Katerndahl DA. Systems and complexity thinking in the general practice literature: an integrative, historical narrative review. Ann Fam Med. 2014;12(1):66-74. doi:10.1370/afm.1593 
  88. Anderson RA, Crabtree BF, Steele DJ, McDaniel RR Jr. Case study research: the view from complexity science. Qual Health Res. 2005;15(5):669-685. doi:10.1177/1049732305275208 
  89. Sturmberg JP, Martin CM. Handbook of systems and complexity in Health. New York: Springer Science+Business Media; 2013.
  90. Mowles C. Complex, but not quite complex enough: The turn to the complexity sciences in evaluation scholarship. Evaluation. 2014;20(2):160-175. doi:10.1177/1356389014527885
  91. Mowles C, Stacey R, Griffin D. What contribution can insights from the complexity sciences make to the theory and practice of development management? J Int Dev. 2008;20(6):804-820. doi:10.1002/jid.1497
  92. Stacey RD. Strategic Management and Organisational Dynamics. 5th ed. Financial Times Prentice Hall; 2007.
  93. Paley J. The appropriation of complexity theory in health care. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2010;15(1):59-61. doi:10.1258/jhsrp.2009.009072
  94. Chia R. From Complexity Science to Complex Thinking: Organization as Simple Location. Organization. 1998;5(3):341-369. doi:10.1177/135050849853003
  95. Tsoukas H. Complex knowledge: Studies in organizational epistemology. Oxford University Press; 2005.
  96. Tsoukas H, Hatch MJ. Complex Thinking, Complex Practice: The Case for a Narrative Approach to Organizational Complexity. Hum Relat. 2001;54(8):979-1013. doi:10.1177/0018726701548001
  97. Yukl G. An evaluation of conceptual weaknesses in transformational and charismatic leadership theories. Leadersh Q. 1999;10(2):285-305. doi:10.1016/S1048-9843(99)00013-2
  98. Anderson RA, Issel LM, McDaniel RR, Jr. Nursing homes as complex adaptive systems: relationship between management practice and resident outcomes. Nurs Res. 2003;52(1):12-21. 
  99. Snowden DJ, Boone ME. A leader's framework for decision making. Harv Bus Rev. 2007;85(11):68-76.
  100. Glouberman S, Zimmerman B. Complicated and complex systems: what would successful reform of Medicare look like? Commission on the future of Health Care in Canada; 2002.
  101. Uhl-Bien M. Complexity Leadership: Part 1. USA: Information Age Publishing; 2008.
  102. Lichtenstein BB, Plowman DA. The leadership of emergence: A complex systems leadership theory of emergence at successive organizational levels. Leadersh Q. 2009;20(4):617-630. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2009.04.006
  103. Marion R, Uhl-Bien M. Introduction to Leadership Quarterly Special Issue on Leadership and Complexity. Leadersh Q. 2007;18(4):293-296. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2007.04.001
  104. Hazy JK, Goldstein JA, Lichtenstein BB. Complex systems leadership theory: New perspectives from complexity science on social and organizational effectiveness. ISCE Publishing; 2007.
  105. Uhl-Bien M, Marion R. Complexity leadership in bureaucratic forms of organizing: A meso model. Leadersh Q. 2009;20(4):631-665. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2009.04.007
  106. Goldstein J, Hazy JK, Lichtenstein BB. Complexity and the nexus of leadership: Leveraging nonlinear science to create ecologies of innovation. Vol 8. Palgrave Macmillan; 2010.
  107. Hazy JK. Complexity Thinking & Leadership: How Nonlinear Models of Human Organizing Dynamics Can Inform Management Practice. Adelphi University School of Business Working; 2010.
  108. Marion R, Uhl-Bien M. Leadership in complex organizations. Leadersh Q. 2001;12(4):389-418. doi:10.1016/S1048-9843(01)00092-3
  109. Avolio BJ, Walumbwa FO, Weber TJ. Leadership: current theories, research, and future directions. Annu Rev Psychol. 2009;60:421-449. doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.60.110707.163621
  110. Clancy TR, Effken JA, Pesut D. Applications of complex systems theory in nursing education, research, and practice. Nurs Outlook. 2008;56(5):248-256.e243. doi:10.1016/j.outlook.2008.06.010
  111. Carter DR, DeChurch LA, Braun MT, Contractor NS. Social network approaches to leadership: an integrative conceptual review. J Appl Psychol. 2015;100(3):597-622. doi:10.1037/a0038922
  112. Mjoset L. The Contextualist Approach to social science methodology. In: Byrne D, Ragin CC, eds. The SAGE Handbook of Case-Based Methods. London: SAGE Publications; 2009.
  113. Dooley KJ, Lichtenstein BB. Research methods for studying the complexity dynamics of leadership. In: Uhl-Bien M, ed. Complexity leadership. Part 1. Information Age Publishing; 2008.
  114. Boyatzis RE. Leadership development from a complexity perspective. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research. 2008;60(4):298-313. doi:10.1037/1065-9293.60.4.298
  115. Ragin CC. Redesigning social inquiry: Fuzzy sets and beyond. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 2008.
  116. Ragin CC. The Comparative Method: Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies. Oakland, California, USA: University of California Press; 2014.
  117. Castellani B, Hafferty FW. Sociology and Complexity Science: A New Field of Inquiry. USA: Springer; 2009.
  118. Grant MJ, Booth A. A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Info Libr J. 2009;26(2):91-108. doi:10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x
  119. Booth A, Papaioannou D, Sutton A. Systematic Approaches to a Successful Literature Review. London: SAGE Publications Ltd; 2011.