Government Actions and Their Relation to Resilience in Healthcare During the COVID-19 Pandemic in New South Wales, Australia and Ontario, Canada

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Queen’s University, Kingston, ON, Canada

2 Australian Institute of Health Innovation, Macquarie University, Sydney, NSW, Australia

Abstract

Background 
Resilience, a system’s ability to maintain a desired level of performance when circumstances disturb its functioning, is an increasingly important concept in healthcare. However, empirical investigations of resilience in healthcare (RiH) remain uncommon, particularly those that examine how government actions contribute to the capacity for resilient performance in the healthcare setting. We sought to investigate how governmental actions during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic related to the concept of resilience, how these actions contributed to the potential for resilient performance in healthcare, and what opportunities exist for governments to foster resilience within healthcare systems.
 

Methods 
We conducted case studies of government actions pertaining to the COVID-19 pandemic in New South Wales, Australia and Ontario, Canada. Using media releases issued by each government between December 2019 and August 2020, we performed qualitative content analysis to identify themes relevant to the resilience potentials (anticipate, monitor, respond, learn) and RiH.
 

Results 
Direct references to the term ‘resilience’ appeared in the media releases of both governments. However, these references focused on the reactive aspects of resilience. While actions that constitute the resilience potentials were evident, the media releases also revealed opportunities to enhance learning (eg, a need to capitalize on opportunities for double-loop learning and identify strategies appropriate for complex systems) and anticipating (eg, incorporating the concept of hedging into frameworks of RiH).
 

Conclusion 
Though fostering RiH through government action remains a challenge, this study suggests opportunities to realize this goal. Articulating a proactive vision of resilience and recognizing the complex nature of current systems could enhance governments’ ability to coordinate resilient performance in healthcare. Reflection on how anticipation relates to resilience appears necessary at both the practical and conceptual levels to further develop the capacity for RiH.

Keywords


  1. Holling CS. Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annu Rev Ecol Syst. 1973;4:1-23. doi:10.1146/annurev.es.04.110173.000245
  2. Ellis LA, Churruca K, Clay-Williams R, et al. Patterns of resilience: a scoping review and bibliometric analysis of resilient health care. Saf Sci. 2019;118:241-257. doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2019.04.044
  3. Woods DD. Four concepts for resilience and the implications for the future of resilience engineering. Reliab Eng Syst Saf. 2015;141:5-9. doi:10.1016/j.ress.2015.03.018
  4. Hollnagel E, Braithwaite J, Wears RL. Resilient Health Care. Farnham, Surrey: Ashgate Publishing Limited; 2013.
  5. Hanefeld J, Mayhew S, Legido-Quigley H, et al. Towards an understanding of resilience: responding to health systems shocks. Health Policy Plan. 2018;33(3):355-367. doi:10.1093/heapol/czx183
  6. Biddle L, Wahedi K, Bozorgmehr K. Health system resilience: a literature review of empirical research. Health Policy Plan. 2020;35(8):1084-1109. doi:10.1093/heapol/czaa032
  7. Wiig S, Fahlbruch B. Exploring Resilience: A Scientific Journey from Practice to Theory. Cham: Springer; 2019.
  8. Hollnagel E, Woods DD, Leveson N. Resilience Engineering: Concepts and Precepts. Farnham, Surrey: Ashgate Publishing Limited; 2006.
  9. Comfort LK, Boin A, Demchak CC. Designing Resilience: Preparing for Extreme Events. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press; 2010.
  10. Braithwaite J, Wears RL, Hollnagel E. Resilient health care: turning patient safety on its head. Int J Qual Health Care. 2015;27(5):418-420. doi:10.1093/intqhc/mzv063
  11. Anderson JE, Ross AJ, Macrae C, Wiig S. Defining adaptive capacity in healthcare: a new framework for researching resilient performance. Appl Ergon. 2020;87:103111. doi:10.1016/j.apergo.2020.103111
  12. Braithwaite J, Wears RL, Hollnagel E. Resilient Health Care: Reconciling Work-as-Imagined and Work-as-Done. Vol 3. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 2017.
  13. Fridell M, Edwin S, von Schreeb J, Saulnier DD. Health system resilience: what are we talking about? a scoping review mapping characteristics and keywords. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2020;9(1):6-16. doi:10.15171/ijhpm.2019.71
  14. Blanchet K, Nam SL, Ramalingam B, Pozo-Martin F. Governance and capacity to manage resilience of health systems: towards a new conceptual framework. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2017;6(8):431-435. doi:10.15171/ijhpm.2017.36
  15. Iflaifel M, Lim RH, Ryan K, Crowley C. Resilient Health Care: a systematic review of conceptualisations, study methods and factors that develop resilience. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020;20(1):324. doi:10.1186/s12913-020-05208-3
  16. Wiig S, Aase K, Billett S, et al. Defining the boundaries and operational concepts of resilience in the resilience in healthcare research program. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020;20(1):330. doi:10.1186/s12913-020-05224-3
  17. Hollnagel E. Safety-II in Practice. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge; 2018.
  18. Braithwaite J. Changing how we think about healthcare improvement. BMJ. 2018;361:k2014. doi:10.1136/bmj.k2014
  19. Wears RL, Hunte GS. Seeing patient safety ‘Like a State’. Saf Sci. 2014;67:50-57. doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2014.02.007
  20. Braithwaite J, Runciman WB, Merry AF. Towards safer, better healthcare: harnessing the natural properties of complex sociotechnical systems. Qual Saf Health Care. 2009;18(1):37-41. doi:10.1136/qshc.2007.023317
  21. Macrae C, Wiig S. Resilience: from practice to theory and back again. In: Wiig S, Fahlbruch B, eds. Exploring Resilience: A Scientific Journey from Practice to Theory. Cham: Springer; 2019:121-128. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-03189-3_15
  22. Berg SH, Akerjordet K, Ekstedt M, Aase K. Methodological strategies in resilient health care studies: an integrative review. Saf Sci. 2018;110(Pt A):300-312. doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2018.08.025
  23. Øyri SF, Braut GS, Macrae C, Wiig S. Exploring links between resilience and the macro-level development of healthcare regulation- a Norwegian case study. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020;20(1):762. doi:10.1186/s12913-020-05513-x
  24. Montgomery A, Panagopoulou E, Esmail A, Richards T, Maslach C. Burnout in healthcare: the case for organisational change. BMJ. 2019;366:l4774. doi:10.1136/bmj.l4774
  25. Wright AA, Katz IT. Beyond burnout - redesigning care to restore meaning and sanity for physicians. N Engl J Med. 2018;378(4):309-311. doi:10.1056/NEJMp1716845
  26. Cook R, Rasmussen J. "Going solid": a model of system dynamics and consequences for patient safety. Qual Saf Health Care. 2005;14(2):130-134. doi:10.1136/qshc.2003.009530
  27. Provan DJ, Woods DD, Dekker SWA, Rae AJ. Safety II professionals: how resilience engineering can transform safety practice. Reliab Eng Syst Saf. 2020;195:106740. doi:10.1016/j.ress.2019.106740
  28. Naming the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) and the virus that causes it. World Health Organization website. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/technical-guidance/naming-the-coronavirus-disease-(covid-2019)-and-the-virus-that-causes-it. Updated 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  29. Timeline: WHO’s response to COVID-19. World Health Organization website. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/interactive-timeline. Updated 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  30. Berlin DA, Gulick RM, Martinez FJ. Severe COVID-19. N Engl J Med. 2020;383(25):2451-2460. doi:10.1056/NEJMcp2009575
  31. Wiersinga WJ, Rhodes A, Cheng AC, Peacock SJ, Prescott HC. Pathophysiology, transmission, diagnosis, and treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): a review. JAMA. 2020;324(8):782-793. doi:10.1001/jama.2020.12839
  32. He X, Lau EHY, Wu P, et al. Temporal dynamics in viral shedding and transmissibility of COVID-19. Nat Med. 2020;26(5):672-675. doi:10.1038/s41591-020-0869-5
  33. Blumenthal D, Fowler EJ, Abrams M, Collins SR. COVID-19 - implications for the health care system. N Engl J Med. 2020;383(15):1483-1488. doi:10.1056/NEJMsb2021088
  34. Scally G, Jacobson B, Abbasi K. The UK's public health response to COVID-19. BMJ. 2020;369:m1932. doi:10.1136/bmj.m1932
  35. Tanne JH, Hayasaki E, Zastrow M, Pulla P, Smith P, Rada AG. COVID-19: how doctors and healthcare systems are tackling coronavirus worldwide. BMJ. 2020;368:m1090. doi:10.1136/bmj.m1090
  36. Janssen M, van der Voort H. Agile and adaptive governance in crisis response: lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic. Int J Inf Manage. 2020;55:102180. doi:10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2020.102180
  37. Chua AQ, Tan MMJ, Verma M, et al. Health system resilience in managing the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons from Singapore. BMJ Glob Health. 2020;5(9):e003317. doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2020-003317
  38. Argyris C. Double loop learning in organizations. Harv Bus Rev. 1977;55(5):115-125.
  39. Crowe S, Cresswell K, Robertson A, Huby G, Avery A, Sheikh A. The case study approach. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2011;11:100. doi:10.1186/1471-2288-11-100
  40. Yin RK. Case Study Research and Applications: Design and Methods. 6th ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications; 2018.
  41. Campbell A. Spring of Fear: Executive Summary. Toronto, ON: The SARS Commission; 2006. http://www.archives.gov.on.ca/en/e_records/sars/report/v1.html. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  42. Webster P. Canada and COVID-19: learning from SARS. Lancet. 2020;395(10228):936-937. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(20)30670-x
  43. Bogart N, Forani J. Then and now: The “huge differences” between SARS and Wuhan coronavirus. CTV News. January 21, 2020. https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/then-and-now-the-huge-differences-between-sars-and-wuhan-coronavirus-1.4777400. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  44. Barton R. In 2003, Canada failed the pandemic test. Here’s what we’ve learned since. CBC News. March 11, 2020. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/sars-toronto-coronavirus-pandemic-1.5492807. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  45. NSW critical infrastructure resilience strategy. NSW Government website. https://www.emergency.nsw.gov.au/criticalinfrastructure. Updated September 14, 2018. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  46. West S, Visentin DC, Neil A, Kornhaber R, Ingham V, Cleary M. Forging, protecting, and repairing community resilience informed by the 2019-2020 Australian bushfires. J Adv Nurs. 2020;76(5):1095-1097. doi:10.1111/jan.14306
  47. Vardoulakis S, Marks G, Abramson MJ. Lessons learned from the Australian bushfires: climate change, air pollution, and public health. JAMA Intern Med. 2020;180(5):635-636. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2020.0703
  48. Become an Ontario health team. Ontario Ministry of Health and Ministry of Long-Term Care website. https://health.gov.on.ca/en/pro/programs/connectedcare/oht/default.aspx. Updated May 14, 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  49. Bill 41, Patients First Act, 2016. Legislative Assembly of Ontario website. https://www.ola.org/en/legislative-business/bills/parliament-41/session-2/bill-41. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  50. Bill 74, the People’s Health Care Act, 2019. Legislative Assembly of Ontario website. https://www.ola.org/en/legislative-business/bills/parliament-42/session-1/bill-74. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  51. Crawley M. What you need to know about Ontario’s new model for health care. CBC News. March 1, 2019. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/what-are-ontario-health-teams-doug-ford-government-1.5035750. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  52. Hallway health care: A system under strain. Ontario Ministry of Health and Ministry of Long-Term Care website. https://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/public/publications/premiers_council/report.aspx. Updated January 31, 2019. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  53. Health services amendment (local health districts and boards) Bill 2011. Parliament of New South Wales website. https://www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/bills/Pages/bill-details.aspx?pk=66. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  54. Governance of local health districts. Audit Office of New South Wales website. https://www.audit.nsw.gov.au/our-work/reports/governance-of-local-health-districts. Updated April 18, 2019. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  55. Brintnell M. In Search of the Perfect Health System. London: Palgrave Macmillan; 2015.
  56. National, state and territory population. Australian Bureau of Statistics website. https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/population/national-state-and-territory-population/latest-release. Updated March 18, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  57. Table 17-10-0009-01 Population estimates, quarterly. Statistics Canada website. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/cv.action?pid=1710000901. Updated May 16, 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  58. Australian national accounts: State accounts. Australian Bureau of Statistics website. https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/economy/national-accounts/australian-national-accounts-state-accounts/latest-release. Updated November 20, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  59. Table 36-10-0222-01 Gross domestic product, expenditure-based, provincial and territorial, annual (x 1,000,000). Statistics Canada website. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/cv.action?pid=3610022201. Updated May 16, 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  60. Health expenditure Australia 2018-9. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare website. https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/health-welfare-expenditure/health-expenditure-australia-2018-19/contents/data-visualisation. Updated November 6, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  61. National health expenditure trends, 1975 to 2019. Canadian Institute for Health Information website. https://www.cihi.ca/sites/default/files/document/nhex-trends-narrative-report-2019-en-web.pdf. Updated 2019. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  62. Hospital resources 2017-18: Australian hospital statistics. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare website. https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/hospitals/hospital-resources-2017-18-ahs/data. Updated June 26, 2019. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  63. OECD interactive tool: International comparisons – Peer countries, Ontario. Canadian Institute for Health Information website. https://www.cihi.ca/en/oecd-interactive-tool-peer-countries-on. Updated March 30, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  64. Conversion rates - Purchasing power parities (PPP) (indicator). OECD website. https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-ppp.htm#indicator-chart. Accessed May 16, 2021. doi:10.1787/1290ee5a-en
  65. Coronavirus cases confirmed in NSW. NSW Health website. https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/news/Pages/20200125_03.aspx. Updated January 25, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  66. Ontario confirms first case of Wuhan novel coronavirus. Ontario Newsroom website. https://news.ontario.ca/en/release/55486/ontario-confirms-first-case-of-wuhan-novel-coronavirus. Updated January 25, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  67. All Ontario: Case numbers and spread. Government of Ontario website. https://covid-19.ontario.ca/data. Updated May 16, 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  68. Coronavirus (COVID-19) statistics. NSW Health website. https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/news/Pages/20200314_00.aspx. Updated March 14, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  69. COVID-19 cases in NSW rise to 22. NSW Health website. https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/news/Pages/20200304_06.aspx. Updated March 4, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  70. Death in Ontario potentially related to COVID-19. Ontario Newsroom website. https://news.ontario.ca/en/statement/56358/death-in-ontario-potentially-related-to-covid-19. Updated March 17, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  71. NSW COVID-19 cases data. NSW Government website. https://data.nsw.gov.au/nsw-covid-19-data/cases. Updated 2021. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  72. 2020 media releases from NSW Health. NSW Health website. https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/news/Pages/2020-nsw-health.aspx. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  73. Zhu N, Zhang D, Wang W, et al. A novel coronavirus from patients with pneumonia in China, 2019. N Engl J Med. 2020;382(8):727-733. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2001017
  74. Ontario releases plan for safe reopening of schools in September. Ontario Newsroom website. https://news.ontario.ca/en/release/57838/ontario-releases-plan-for-safe-reopening-of-schools-in-september. Updated July 30, 2020. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  75. Elo S, Kyngäs H. The qualitative content analysis process. J Adv Nurs. 2008;62(1):107-115. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2648.2007.04569.x
  76. Hsieh HF, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res. 2005;15(9):1277-1288. doi:10.1177/1049732305276687
  77. Perrow C. Normal Accidents: Living with High-Risk Technologies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1999.
  78. Bar-Yam Y. Dynamics of Complex Systems. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley; 1997.
  79. Braithwaite J, Churruca K, Ellis LA, et al. Complexity Science in Healthcare – Aspirations, Approaches, Applications and Accomplishments: A White Paper. Sydney, Australia: Australian Institute of Health Innovation, Macquarie University; 2017.
  80. Plsek PE, Greenhalgh T. Complexity science: the challenge of complexity in health care. BMJ. 2001;323(7313):625-628. doi:10.1136/bmj.323.7313.625
  81. Uhl-Bien M, Marion R, McKelvey B. Complexity leadership theory: shifting leadership from the industrial age to the knowledge era. Leadersh Q. 2007;18(4):298-318. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2007.04.002
  82. Balint T, Lamperti F, Mandel A, Napoletano M, Roventini A, Sapio A. Complexity and the economics of climate change: a survey and a look forward. Ecol Econ. 2017;138:252-265. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2017.03.032
  83. Campbell A. Spring of Fear: Final Report. Toronto, ON: The SARS Commission; 2006. http://www.archives.gov.on.ca/en/e_records/sars/report/index.html. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  84. Tucker AL, Edmondson AC. Why Hospitals Don't Learn from Failures: Organizational and Psychological Dynamics That Inhibit System Change. Calif Manage Rev. 2003;45(2):55-72. doi:10.2307/41166165
  85. Uhl-Bien M, Arena M. Leadership for organizational adaptability: a theoretical synthesis and integrative framework. Leadersh Q. 2018;29(1):89-104. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2017.12.009
  86. Rajon E, Desouhant E, Chevalier M, Débias F, Menu F. The evolution of bet hedging in response to local ecological conditions. Am Nat. 2014;184(1):E1-15. doi:10.1086/676506
  87. Van Mieghem JA. Capacity management, investment, and hedging: Review and recent developments. Manuf Serv Oper Manag. 2003;5(4):269-302. doi:10.1287/msom.5.4.269.24882
  88. Woods DD. Bets against the odds in a pandemic: Which of three coronavirus bets are you willing to gamble on? Zenodo; 2020. doi:10.5281/zenodo.3904528
  89. Russell A. Ontario conducting fewer than 3,000 COVID-19 tests despite daily capacity of 13,000. Global News. April 8, 2020. https://globalnews.ca/news/6793481/coronavirus-covid-19-tests-ontario-capacity/. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  90. Wallace K, Tubb E. Since March, Ontario has used less than 60 per cent of COVID-19 test capacity, Star analysis finds. Toronto Star. June 11, 2020. https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2020/06/10/since-march-ontario-has-used-less-than-60-per-cent-of-covid-19-test-capacity-star-analysis-finds.html. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  91. Crawley M. Why Ontario hospitals are full to bursting, despite few COVID-19 patients. CBC News. November 2, 2020. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-hospital-occupancy-covid-19-hallway-healthcare-1.5784075. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  92. Blau A, Martino M. Coronavirus could flood our hospital ICUs with COVID-19 patients, so do we have enough beds? ABC News. March 26, 2020. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-27/coronavirus-australia-covid-19-icu-beds-ventilators-hospitals/12090420?nw=0&pfmredir=sm. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  93. Dubinsky Z, McKenna T, Loiero J, Leung A. As ICUs fill up, doctors confront grim choice of who gets life-saving care. CBC News. April 19, 2021. https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/covid-ontario-icu-triage-1.5992188. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  94. McKenzie-Sutter H. Coronavirus: Ontario government rejects long-term care commissioners’ appeal for more inquiry time. Global News. January 4, 2021. https://globalnews.ca/news/7554124/coronavirus-ontario-long-term-care-commission-time-extension/. Accessed May 16, 2021.
  95. Ling J. How Ontario’s health advisors handled the “darkest day” of the pandemic. Macleans. April 20, 2021. https://www.macleans.ca/society/health/how-ontarios-health-advisors-handled-the-darkest-day-of-the-pandemic/. Accessed May 16, 2021.

Articles in Press, Corrected Proof
Available Online from 06 July 2021
  • Receive Date: 08 March 2021
  • Revise Date: 19 May 2021
  • Accept Date: 08 June 2021