The Electronic Health Insurance Card for Asylum-Seekers in Berlin: Effects on the Local Health System

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Department of Health Care Management, Technical University Berlin, Berlin, Germany

2 Department of Population Medicine and Health Services Research, School of Public Health, Bielefeld University, Bielefeld, Germany

3 Berlin School of Public Health, Berlin, Germany

Abstract

Background 
In debates on asylum-seekers’ access to healthcare it is frequently claimed that restrictions are necessary to prevent unduly high health service utilization and costs. Within Germany, healthcare provision for asylum-seekers varies across the different states. Berlin’s authorities removed some barriers to healthcare for asylum-seekers by introducing an electronic health insurance card (HIC) in 2016. We used the HIC introduction in Berlin as an opportunity to investigate the effects of improved healthcare access for asylum-seekers on the local health system.
 
Methods 
The study applied a mixed-methods design. A cost analysis compared expenses for outpatient and inpatient health services for asylum-seekers before and after the HIC introduction, based on aggregate claims data and information on expenses for humanitarian healthcare provision that were retrieved from the Berlin authorities. Semi- structured interviews with 12 key informants explored organizational effects like administrative workloads and ethical dilemmas for staff. We performed a content analysis and used respondent validation to enhance the accuracy and trustworthiness of our results.
 
Results 
The HIC has reduced bureaucratic complexity and administrative workloads; it has enabled unprecedented financial transparency and control; and it has mitigated ethical tensions. All the while, average per person expenses for outpatient health services have declined since the HIC introduction. However, our cost analysis also indicates a rise in the utilization and costs of inpatient care.
 
Conclusion 
The HIC introduction in Berlin suggests that the removal of barriers to healthcare for asylum-seekers can create win-win-situations by reducing administrative workloads, advancing financial transparency, and mitigating ethical tensions, whilst cutting the costs of outpatient healthcare provision. Removing barriers to healthcare thus appears to be a more prudent policy choice than maintaining mechanisms of restriction and control. However, high inpatient care utilization and costs warrant further research.

Keywords


  1. Press release: Vereinbarung zur Einführung der elektronischen Gesundheitskarte für Flüchtlinge unterzeichnet. Berlin: Senatsverwaltung für Gesundheit und Soziales; 2015. https://www.berlin.de/sen/archiv/gessoz-2011-2016/2015/pressemitteilung.423518.php.  Accessed August 3, 2020. [German].
  2. Bozorgmehr K, Razum O. Negotiating access to health care for asylum seekers in Germany. In: Severoni S, Kosinska M, Immordino P, Kökény M, Told M, eds. Health Diplomacy: Spotlight on Refugees and Migrants. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2019:163-169.
  3. Gottlieb N, Schülle M. An overview of health policies for asylum-seekers in Germany. Health Policy. 2021;125(1):115-121. doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2020.09.009
  4. Wahrendorf V. Einleitung Asylbewerberleistungsgesetz. In: Grube M, Wahrendorf V, eds. SGB XII Sozialhilfe. Munich: C.H. Beck; 2012.
  5. Razum O, Wenner J, Bozorgmehr K. Wenn Zufall über den Zugang zur Gesundheitsversorgung bestimmt: Geflüchtete in Deutschland [German]. Gesundheitswesen. 2016;78(11):711-714. doi:10.1055/s-0042-116231
  6. Wächter-Raquet M. Einführung der Gesundheitskarte für Asylsuchende und Flüchtlinge: der Umsetzungsstand im Überblick der Bundesländer. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Stiftung; 2016. [German].
  7. Gesundheit für Geflüchtete. Informationsportal von Medibüros/Medinetzen. http://gesundheit-gefluechtete.info/gesundheitskarte/.  Accessed August 3, 2020. [German].
  8. Rolke K, Wenner J, Razum O. Shaping access to health care for refugees on the local level in Germany – Mixed-methods analysis of official statistics and perspectives of gatekeepers. Health Policy. 2019;123(9):845-850. doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2019.07.001
  9. Schnack D, Kötter J. Flüchtlingsversorgung. Streitpunkt Gesundheitskarte. Ärzte Zeitung; 2016. https://www.aerztezeitung.de/Panorama/Streitpunkt-Gesundheitskarte-235676.html.  Published January 25, 2016. Accessed August 3, 2020. [German].
  10. Burmester F. Statutory health insurance companies and their role according medical care for asylum seekers in Hamburg. Public Health Forum. 2015;23(2):106-108. doi:10.1515/pubhef-2015-0039
  11. Lichtl C, Gewalt SC, Noest S, Szecsenyi J, Bozorgmehr K. Potentially avoidable and ambulatory care sensitive hospitalisations among forced migrants: a protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open. 2016;6(9):e012216. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2016-012216
  12. Bauhoff S, Göpffarth D. Asylum-seekers in Germany differ from regularly insured in their morbidity, utilizations and costs of care. PLoS One. 2018;13(5):e0197881. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0197881
  13. Trummer U, Novak-Zezula S, Renner A, Wilczewska I. Cost Savings Through Timely Treatment for Irregular Migrants and EU Citizens Without Insurance. http://c-hm.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Info_CHM_V11.pdf.  Accessed August 3, 2020. Published 2016.
  14. Bozorgmehr K, Razum O. Effect of restricting access to health care on health expenditures among asylum-seekers and refugees: a quasi-experimental study in Germany, 1994-2013. PLoS One. 2015; 10(7):e0131483. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0131483
  15. Zentrale Ethikkommission bei der Bundesärztekammer (ZEKO). Versorgung von nicht regulär krankenversicherten Patienten mit Migrationshintergrund. Dtsch Arztebl. 2013;110:A899-903. [German].
  16. Press release: Montgomery fordert Gesundheitskarte für Flüchtlinge. Bundesärztekammer.  https://www.bundesaerztekammer.de/presse/pressemitteilungen/news-detail/montgomery-fordert-gesundheitskarte-fuer-fluechtlinge/.    Accessed August 3, 2020. Published September 17, 2015. [German].
  17. Ohm V, Knörnschild M, Gottlieb N. Die elektronischen Gesundheitskarte für Asylsuchende in Berlin: eine erste Bilanz. Zeitschrift für Flucht- und Flüchtlingsforsch; In Press. [German].
  18. Curry LA, Krumholz HM, O’Cathain A, Plano Clark VL, Cherlin E, Bradley EH. Mixed methods in biomedical and health services research. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes. 2013;6(1):119-123. doi:10.1161/circoutcomes.112.967885
  19. Fetters MD, Curry LA, Creswell JW. Achieving integration in mixed methods designs-principles and practices. Health Serv Res. 2013;48(6 Pt 2):2134-2156. doi:10.1111/1475-6773.12117
  20. Hollederer A. Guarantee of illness assistance for people seeking asylum: two-tiered medical system in Germany? [German]. Bundesgesundheitsblatt Gesundheitsforschung Gesundheitsschutz. 2020;63(10):1203-1218. doi:10.1007/s00103-020-03215-7
  21. Niedermaier A, Freiberg A, Tiller D, Wienke A, Führer A. Outpatient health care utilization and health expenditures of asylum seekers in Halle (Saale), Germany - an analysis of claims data. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020;20(1):961. doi:10.1186/s12913-020-05811-4
  22. Jäger P, Claassen K, Ott N, Brand A. Does the electronic health card for asylum seekers lead to an excessive use of the health system? Results of a survey in two municipalities of the German Ruhr area. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2019;16(7):1178. doi:10.3390/ijerph16071178
  23. Wenner J, Rolke K, Breckenkamp J, Sauzet O, Bozorgmehr K, Razum O. Inequalities in realised access to healthcare among recently arrived refugees depending on local access model: study protocol for a quasi-experimental study. BMJ Open. 2019;9(5):e027357. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2018-027357
  24. Seipel C, Rieker P. Integrative Sozialforschung: Konzepte und Methoden der qualitativen und quantitativen empirischen Forschung. Weinheim: Juventa; 2003. [German].
  25. Scientific Software Development G. ATLAS.ti. 2019. https://atlasti.com/product/what-is-atlas-ti/.  Accessed August 3, 2020.
  26. Biddle L, Menold N, Bentner M, et al. Health monitoring among asylum seekers and refugees: a state-wide, cross-sectional, population-based study in Germany. Emerg Themes Epidemiol. 2019;16:3. doi:10.1186/s12982-019-0085-2
  27. Starfield B. Improving equity in health: a research agenda. Int J Health Serv. 2001;31(3):545-566. doi:10.2190/dgj8-4mqw-up9j-lqc1
  28. Gottlieb N, Püschmann C, Stenzinger F, et al. Health and Healthcare Utilization among Asylum-Seekers from Berlin’s LGBTIQ Shelter: Preliminary Results of a Survey. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020; 17(12):4514. doi:10.3390/ijerph17124514
  29. Amoah DN. Examining the Association Between Mental Health Need and the Utilization of Health Care Among Asylum-Seekers and Refugees in Municipal Housing in Berlin [MPH thesis]. Berlin: Berlin School of Public Health; 2019.
  30. Bosswick W. Development of asylum policy in Germany. J Refug Stud. 2000;13(1):43-60. doi:10.1093/jrs/13.1.43
  31. Bade KJ, Oltmer J. Flucht und Asyl seit 1990. Bonn: Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung; 2005. [German].
  32. Gottlieb N, Trummer U, Davidovitch N, et al. Economic arguments in migrant health policymaking: proposing a research agenda. Global Health. 2020;16(1):113. doi:10.1186/s12992-020-00642-8
  33. Karl-Trummer U, Novak-Zezula S, Metzler B. Managing a paradox: health care for undocumented migrants in the EU. Finnish J Ethn Migr. 2009;4(2):53-60.
  34. Jensen NK, Norredam M, Draebel T, Bogic M, Priebe S, Krasnik A. Providing medical care for undocumented migrants in Denmark: what are the challenges for health professionals? BMC Health Serv Res. 2011; 11:154. doi:10.1186/1472-6963-11-154
  35. Lafaut D. ‘If he dies with the papers of his brother, his brother will be considered dead’. Moral understandings of health professionals about the use of deception to overcome restrictions in access to healthcare. Clin Ethics. 2020;15(2):84-93. doi:10.1177/1477750920903460
  36. Gottlieb N, Davidovitch N. Migrant health: putting the economic argument into the context of deservingness debates. Eur J Public Health. 2017; 27(4):591-592. doi:10.1093/eurpub/ckx088