How International Health System Austerity Responses to the 2008 Financial Crisis Impacted Health System and Workforce Resilience – A Realist Review

Document Type : Review Article

Authors

1 Centre for Health Policy and Management, Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland

2 School of Social Work and Social Policy, Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin, College Green, Dublin 2, Ireland

3 FWO, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp, Belgium

4 Everlake, Co Dublin, Ireland

5 Library Reader Services, Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin, St James Hospital, Dublin 8, Ireland

Abstract

Background 
The Great Recession, following the 2008 financial crisis, led many governments to adopt programmes of austerity. This had a lasting impact on health system functionality, resources, staff (numbers, motivation and morale) and patient outcomes. This study aimed to understand how health system resilience was impacted and how this affects readiness for subsequent shocks.

Methods 
A realist review identified legacies associated with austerity (proximal outcomes) and how these impact the distal outcome of health system resilience. EMBASE, CINAHL, MEDLINE, EconLit and Web of Science were searched (2007– May’21), resulting in 1,081 articles. Further theory-driven searches resulted in an additional 60 studies. Descriptive,
inductive, deductive and retroductive realist analysis (utilising excel and Nvivo) aided the development of Context, Mechanism, Outcomes Configurations (CMOCs), alongside stakeholder engagement to confirm or refute emerging results. Causal pathways, and the interplay between context and mechanisms that led to proximal and distal outcomes, were revealed. The refined CMOCs and policy recommendations focused primarily on workforce resilience.


Results 
Five CMOCs demonstrated how austerity-driven policy decisions can impact health systems when driven by the priorities of external agents. This created a real or perceived shift away from the values and interests of health professionals, a distrust in decision-making processes and resistance to change. Their values were at odds with the realities of implementing such policy decisions within sustained restrictive working conditions (rationing of staff, consumables, treatment options). A diminished view of the profession and an inability to provide high-quality, equitable, and needs-led care, alongside stagnant or degraded working conditions, led to moral distress. This can forge legacies that may adversely impact resilience when faced with future shocks.

Conclusion 
This review reveals the importance of transparent, open communication, in addition to co-produced policies in order to avoid scenarios that can be detrimental to workforce and health system resilience.

Keywords


  1. Thomas, S. and P. Fleming. RESTORE - Resilience to Reform: Towards dynamic resilience in health system performance and reform. 2020 [cited 2021; Available from: https://www.tcd.ie/medicine/health_policy_management/research/current/restore/.
  2. Thomas, S., A. Sagan, J. Larkin, et al., Strengthening health systems resilience: Key concepts and strategies in Health Systems and Policy Analysis, A. Sagan, Editor. 2020, European Observatory on Health, Systems Policies, World Health Organization - Regional Office for Europe: Copenhagen, Denmark. p. 33.
  3. Kentikelenis, A. and T. Stubbs, Austerity Redux: The Post-pandemic Wave of Budget Cuts and the Future of Global Public Health. Global Policy, 2022. 13(1): p. 5-17.
  4. Barasa, E.W., K. Cloete, and L. Gilson, From bouncing back, to nurturing emergence : reframing the concept of resilience in health systems strengthening. 2017. 32: p. iii91.
  5. Biddle, L., K. Wahedi, and K. Bozorgmehr, Health system resilience: a literature review of empirical research. Health Policy and Planning, 2020. 35(8): p. 1084-1109.
  6. Blanchet, K., S.L. Nam, B. Ramalingam, and F. Pozo-Martin, Governance and capacity to manage resilience of health systems: towards a new conceptual framework. International journal of health policy and management, 2017. 6(8): p. 431.
  7. Wong, G., G. Westhrop, R. Pawson, and T. Greenhalgh, Realist Synthesis RAMESES Training Materials. 2013, University of Oxford: Oxford.
  8. Barasa, E., R. Mbau, and L. Gilson, What Is Resilience and How Can It Be Nurtured? A Systematic Review of Empirical Literature on Organizational Resilience. 2018. 7(6): p. 491-503.
  9. Pawson, R. and N. Tilley, Realistic evaluation. 1997, London: Sage.
  10. Pawson, R., The science of evaluation : a realist manifesto / Ray Pawson. 2013. p. 0-3.
  11. Pawson, R., T. Greenhalgh, H. Gill, and K. Walshe, Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 2005. 10: p. 21-34.
  12. Greenhalgh, J. and A. Manzano, Understanding ‘context’ in realist evaluation and synthesis. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2021: p. 1-13.
  13. Nielsen, S.B., S. Lemire, and S. Tangsig, Unpacking context in realist evaluations: Findings from a comprehensive review. Evaluation, 2021. 28(1): p. 91-112.
  14. De Souza, D.E., A critical realist approach to systems thinking in evaluation. Evaluation, 2022. 28(1): p. 72-90.
  15. Astbury, B. and F.L. Leeuw, Unpacking Black Boxes: Mechanisms and Theory Building in Evaluation. 2010. 31(3): p. 363-381.
  16. Fleming, P., L. Caffrey, D. Mockler, and S. Thomas, PROTOCOL: A realist review to determine how health system austerity responses to the 2008 financial crisis impacted health system resilience for subsequent shocks - why, when, for whom and under what circumstances. PROSPERO - International prospective register of systematic reviews, 2021(CRD42021264112 ).
  17. Thomas, S., S. Burke, A. Sagan, et al., RESTORE - Measuring and Building Health System Resilience - 1st Annual Workshop. 2021, Centre for Health Policy and Management, Trinity College Dublin: Dublin.
  18. Fleming, P., L. Caffrey, D. Mockler, and S. Thomas, The legacy of health system responses to the 2008 financial crisis and how this impacted health system resilience – A realist review, in SPHeRE Network 8th Annual Conference - Wicked Policy Problems - Pulling Back the Curtain. March 29th 2022, SPHeRE Structured Population and Health-services Research Education: Online.
  19. Harzing, A.W. Publish or Perish. 2007 [cited 2021; Available from: https://harzing.com/resources/publish-or-perish.
  20. COVIDENCE, Covidence systematic review software. 2021, Veritas Health Innovation: Melbourne, Australia.
  21. Greenhalgh, T., R. Pawson, G. Wong, et al., Retroduction in realist evaluation - the RAMESES II project. 2017: UK.
  22. Greenhalgh, T., R. Pawson, G. Wong, et al., "Theory" in realist evaluation - the RAMESES II project. 2017: UK.
  23. Wong, G. and C. Duddy, Data analysis - realist evaluations. 2021, Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford: Oxford.
  24. Aiken, L.H., D.M. Sloane, L. Bruyneel, et al., Nurse staffing and education and hospital mortality in nine European countries: A retrospective observational study. The Lancet, 2014. 383(9931): p. 1824-1830.
  25. Borra, C., J. Pons-Pons, and M. Vilar-Rodríguez, Austerity, healthcare provision, and health outcomes in Spain. European Journal of Health Economics, 2020. 21(3): p. 409-423.
  26. Green, M.A., D. Dorling, J. Minton, and K.E. Pickett, Could the rise in mortality rates since 2015 be explained by changes in the number of delayed discharges of NHS patients? Journal of epidemiology and community health, 2017. 71(11): p. 1068-1071.
  27. Owusu, P.A., S.A. Sarkodie, and P.A. Pedersen, Relationship between mortality and health care expenditure: Sustainable assessment of health care system. PLoS ONE, 2021. 16(2 February 2021).
  28. Tyrovolas, S., N.J. Kassebaum, A. Stergachis, et al., The burden of disease in Greece, health loss, risk factors, and health financing, 2000–16: an analysis of the Global Burden of Disease Study 2016. The Lancet Public Health, 2018. 3(8): p. e395-e406.
  29. Zilidis, C., D. Stuckler, and M. McKee, Use of amenable mortality indicators to evaluate the impact of financial crisis on health system performance in Greece. European Journal of Public Health, 2020. 30(5): p. 861-866.
  30. Córdoba-Doña, J.A., M. San Sebastián, A. Escolar-Pujolar, J.E. Martínez-Faure, and P.E. Gustafsson, Economic crisis and suicidal behaviour: The role of unemployment, sex and age in Andalusia, Southern Spain. International Journal for Equity in Health, 2014. 13(1).
  31. Chang, S.S., D. Stuckler, P. Yip, and D. Gunnell, Impact of 2008 global economic crisis on suicide: Time trend study in 54 countries. BMJ (Online), 2013. 347(7925).
  32. Kontaxakis, V., T. Papaslanis, B. Havaki-Kontaxaki, et al., Suicide in Greece: 2001-2011. Psychiatrikē = Psychiatriki, 2013. 24(3): p. 170-174.
  33. Triantafyllou, K. and C. Angeletopoulou, Increased suicidality amid economic crisis in Greece. Lancet Correspondence, 2011. 378(9801): p. 1459-60.
  34. Barr, B., P. Kinderman, and M. Whitehead, Trends in mental health inequalities in England during a period of recession, austerity and welfare reform 2004 to 2013. Social Science and Medicine, 2015. 147: p. 324-331.
  35. Gili, M., M. Roca, S. Basu, M. McKee, and D. Stuckler, The mental health risks of economic crisis in Spain: evidence from primary care centres, 2006 and 2010. The European Journal of Public Health, 2013. 23(1): p. 103-108.
  36. Medel-Herrero, A. and M. Gomez-Beneyto, The impact of the 2008 economic crisis on the increasing number of young psychiatric inpatients. Revista de Psiquiatria y Salud Mental, 2019. 12(1): p. 28-36.
  37. Karanikolos, M., V.S. Gordeev, J.P. Mackenbach, and M. McKee, Access to care in the Baltic States: did crisis have an impact? European journal of public health, 2016. 26(2): p. 236-241.
  38. Legido-Quigley, H., M. Karanikolos, S. Hernandez-Plaza, et al., Effects of the financial crisis and Troika austerity measures on health and health care access in Portugal. Health Policy, 2016. 120(7): p. 833-839.
  39. Petrelli, A., A. Rosano, A. Rossi, C. Mirisola, and C. Cislaghi, The geography and economics of forgoing medical examinations or therapeutic treatments in Italy during the economic crisis. BMC public health, 2019. 19(1): p. 1202.
  40. Reeves, A., M. McKee, and D. Stuckler, The attack on universal health coverage in Europe: recession, austerity and unmet needs. European journal of public health, 2015. 25(3): p. 364-365.
  41. Zavras, D., A.I. Zavras, I.I. Kyriopoulos, and J. Kyriopoulos, Economic crisis, austerity and unmet healthcare needs: the case of Greece. BMC health services research, 2016. 16: p. 309.
  42. Anderson, I., H. Axelson, and B.K. Tan, The other crisis: the economics and financing of maternal, newborn and child health in Asia. Health Policy and Planning, 2011. 26(4): p. 288-297.
  43. Bosch, X., P. Moreno, and A. López-Soto, The painful effects of the financial crisis on spanish health care. International Journal of Health Services, 2014. 44(1): p. 25-51.
  44. Golinelli, D., A. Bucci, F. Toscano, F. Filicori, and M.P. Fantini, Real and predicted mortality under health spending constraints in Italy: a time trend analysis through artificial neural networks. BMC health services research, 2018. 18(1): p. 671.
  45. Vandoros, S. and T. Stargardt, Reforms in the Greek pharmaceutical market during the financial crisis. Health Policy, 2013. 109(1): p. 1-6.
  46. Okon, M., A. Henderson, D. Kinnear, and S.A. Cooper, Trends and variations in per capita expenditure on adult intellectual disabilities health and social care across Scotland, and by urban/rural class. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 2019. 32(1): p. 121-130.
  47. Prante, F.J., A. Bramucci, and A. Truger, Decades of Tight Fiscal Policy Have Left the Health Care System in Italy Ill-Prepared to Fight the COVID-19 Outbreak. Inter Econ, 2020. 55(3): p. 147-152.
  48. Chantzaras, A.E. and J.N. Yfantopoulos, Financial protection of households against health shocks in Greece during the economic crisis. Social Science & Medicine, 2018. 211: p. 338-351.
  49. Crookes, C., R. Palladino, P. Seferidi, et al., Impact of the economic crisis on household health expenditure in Greece: an interrupted time series analysis. BMJ Open, 2020. 10(8): p. e038158.
  50. Grima, S., J.V. Spiteri, M. Jakovljevic, C. Camilleri, and S.C. Buttigieg, High Out-of-Pocket Health Spending in Countries With a Mediterranean Connection. Frontiers in Public Health, 2018. 6.
  51. Palasca, S. and S. Enea, THE AFTERMATH OF THE ECONOMIC CRISIS: HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS' INEQUALITIES IN EUROPE. 2014, Centre for European Studies, Alexandru Ioan Cuza University, CES Working Papers.
  52. Palasca, S. and E. Jaba, Economic Crisis' Repercussions on European Healthcare Systems, in 2nd Global Conference on Business, Economics, Management and Tourism, A.I. Iacob, Editor. 2015. p. 525-533.
  53. López-López, S., R. Del Pozo-Rubio, M. Ortega-Ortega, and F. Escribano-Sotos, Catastrophic household expenditure associated with out-of-pocket healthcare payments in Spain. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2021. 18(3): p. 1-18.
  54. Zikidou, S. and S. Hadjidema, Households Health Expenditure in Interannual Correlation With Public Health Expenditure in Greece. Frontiers in Public Health, 2020. 8.
  55. Thomas, S., C. Keegan, S. Barry, and R. Layte, The Irish health system and the economic crisis. The Lancet, 2012. 380(9847): p. 1056-1057.
  56. Karavokyros, I.G., G.I. Kirkilessis, D. Schizas, et al., Emergency inguinal hernioplasties in a tertiary public Hospital in Athens Greece, during the economic crisis. BMC surgery, 2019. 19(1): p. 18.
  57. Lusardi, A., D.J. Schneider, and P. Tufano, The economic crisis and medical care usage. 2010, National Bureau of Economic Research.
  58. Castano, J., J.E. Ospina, J.A. Caylà, and S.L. Greer, Restricting Access to Health Care to Immigrants in Barcelona: A Mixed-Methods Study With Immigrants Who Have Experienced an Infectious Disease. International journal of health services : planning, administration, evaluation, 2016. 46(2): p. 241-261.
  59. Rim, T.H., M. Choi, J.S. Yoon, and S.S. Kim, Sociodemographic and health behavioural factors associated with access to and utilisation of eye care in Korea: Korea Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2008-2012. BMJ Open, 2015. 5(7).
  60. Schneider, S.M. and C. Devitt, Accessing healthcare in times of economic growth and economic downturn: Evidence from Ireland. Journal of European Social Policy, 2018. 28(4): p. 357-369.
  61. Tavares, L.P. and F. Zantomio, Inequity in healthcare use among older people after 2008: The case of southern European countries. Health Policy, 2017. 121(10): p. 1063-1071.
  62. Torfs, L., S. Adriaenssens, S. Lagaert, and S. Willems, The unequal effects of austerity measures between income-groups on the access to healthcare: a quasi-experimental approach. International journal for equity in health, 2021. 20(1): p. 79.
  63. Buchan, J., F. O'May, and G. Dussault, Nursing workforce policy and the economic crisis: A global overview. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 2013. 45(3): p. 298-307.
  64. Burke, R.J., E.S. Ng, and J. Wolpin, Economic austerity and healthcare restructuring: correlates and consequences of nursing job insecurity. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2015. 26(5): p. 640-656.
  65. Koukia, E., P. Mangoulia, N. Gonis, and T. Katostaras, Violence against health care staff by patient’s visitor in general hospital in Greece: Possible causes and economic crisis. Open Journal of Nursing, 2013. 2013.
  66. Galbany-Estragués, P. and S. Nelson, Migration of Spanish nurses 2009?2014. Underemployment and surplus production of Spanish nurses and mobility among Spanish registered nurses: A case study. 2016. 63: p. 112-123.
  67. Glasper, A., Is essential learning being compromised by austerity? British journal of nursing (Mark Allen Publishing), 2015. 24(11): p. 602-603.
  68. Palese, A., C. Vianello, A. Cassone, M. Polonia, and G. Bortoluzzi, Financial austerity measures and their effects as perceived in daily practice by Italian nurses from 2010 to 2011: A longitudinal study. Contemporary nurse, 2014. 48(2): p. 168-180.
  69. Rachiotis, G., C. Kourousis, M. Kamilaraki, et al., Medical supplies shortages and burnout among greek health care workers during economic crisis: A pilot study. International Journal of Medical Sciences, 2014. 11(5): p. 442-447.
  70. Williams, D. and S. Thomas, The impact of austerity on the health workforce and the achievement of human resources for health policies in Ireland (2008-2014). Human Resources for Health, 2017. 15: p. 8.
  71. Solberg, I.B., K. Tómasson, O. Aasland, and R. Tyssen, Cross-national comparison of job satisfaction in doctors during economic recession. Occupational medicine (Oxford, England), 2014. 64(8): p. 595-600.
  72. Currie, J., M.G. Castillo, V. Adekanmbi, B. Barr, and M. O'Flaherty, Evaluating effects of recent changes in NHS resource allocation policy on inequalities in amenable mortality in England, 2007-2014: time-series analysis. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2019. 73(2): p. 162-167.
  73. Polyzos, N., H. Karanikas, E. Thireos, C. Kastanioti, and N. Kontodimopoulos, Reforming reimbursement of public hospitals in Greece during the economic crisis: implementation of a DRG system. Health policy, 2013. 109(1): p. 14-22.
  74. Puig-Junoy, J., S. Rodríguez-Feijoó, and B.G. Lopez-Valcarcel, Paying for formerly free medicines in Spain after 1 year of co-payment: Changes in the number of dispensed prescriptions. Applied Health Economics and Health Policy, 2014. 12(3): p. 279-287.
  75. Carney, M.A., “Sharing One's Destiny”: Effects of austerity on migrant health provisioning in the Mediterranean borderlands. Social Science and Medicine, 2017. 187: p. 251-258.
  76. Kentikelenis, A., M. Karanikolos, A. Reeves, M. McKee, and D. Stuckler, Greece's health crisis: From austerity to denialism. The Lancet, 2014. 383(9918): p. 748-753.
  77. Hollingworth, W., L. Rooshenas, J. Busby, et al., Using clinical practice variations as a method for commissioners and clinicians to identify and prioritise opportunities for disinvestment in health care: a cross-sectional study, systematic reviews and qualitative study. NIHR Journals Library. Health Services and Delivery Research, 2015. 04: p. 04.
  78. Leider, J.P., B. Resnick, and N. Kass, Tradeoffs in resource allocation at state health agencies. Journal of public health management and practice : JPHMP, 2014. 20(6): p. 566-579.
  79. Thomas, S., C. Keegan, S. Barry, et al., A framework for assessing health system resilience in an economic crisis: Ireland as a test case. BMC health services research, 2013. 13: p. 450.
  80. Cervero-Liceras, F., M. McKee, and H. Legido-Quigley, The effects of the financial crisis and austerity measures on the Spanish health care system: A qualitative analysis of health professionals' perceptions in the region of Valencia. Health Policy, 2015. 119(1): p. 100-106.
  81. Fana, T. and J. Goudge, Austerity, resilience and the management of actors in public hospitals: a qualitative study from South Africa. Bmj Global Health, 2021. 6(2).
  82. Gleeson, L.L., G.L. O’Brien, D. O’Mahony, and S. Byrne, Thirst for change in a challenging environment: healthcare providers’ perceptions of safety culture in a large Irish teaching hospital. Irish Journal of Medical Science, 2021.
  83. Olafsdottir, A.E., P. Allotey, and D.D. Reidpath, A health system in economic crises: a case study from Iceland. Scandinavian journal of public health, 2013. 41(2): p. 198-205.

84.Pellinen, J., T. Matto, K. Sippola, and A. Rautiainen, Blame game or dialogue? Financial, professional and democratic accountabilities in a complex health care setting. Accounting Auditing & Accountability Journal, 2018. 31(2): p. 626-650.

  1. Correia, T., G. Dussault, and C. Pontes, The impact of the financial crisis on human resources for health policies in three southern-Europe countries. Health Policy, 2015. 119(12): p. 1600-1605.
  2. Kerasidou, A. and A. Cribb, Austerity, Health and Ethics. Health care analysis : HCA : journal of health philosophy and policy, 2019. 27(3): p. 153-156.
  3. Kerasidou, A., Empathy and Efficiency in Healthcare at Times of Austerity. Health care analysis : HCA : journal of health philosophy and policy, 2019. 27(3): p. 171-184.
  4. Barradas, C.D.S. and J.A. Nunes, Facing austerity: the decline in health access and quality of care for patients with cancer in Portugal. Historia, ciencias, saude--Manguinhos, 2017. 24(4): p. 933-951.
  5. Russo, G., I. Rego, J. Perelman, and P.P. Barros, A tale of loss of privilege, resilience and change: the impact of the economic crisis on physicians and medical services in Portugal. Health Policy, 2016. 120(9): p. 1079-1086.
  6. Tucker, R., F. Moffatt, and S. Timmons, Austerity on the frontline- a preliminary study of physiotherapists working in the National Health Service in the UK. Physiotherapy theory and practice, 2020: p. 1-13.
  7. Papadakaki, M., C. Lionis, A. Saridaki, et al., Exploring barriers to primary care for migrants in Greece in times of austerity: Perspectives of service providers. European Journal of General Practice, 2017. 23(1): p. 128-134.
  8. Balfe, M., R. Brugha, D. Smith, et al., Considering quality of care for young adults with diabetes in Ireland. BMC health services research, 2013. 13: p. 448.
  9. Humphries, N., A. McDermott, E. Conway, et al., ‘Everything was just getting worse and worse’: deteriorating job quality as a driver of doctor emigration from Ireland. Human resources for health, 2019. 17(1): p. 1-11.
  10. Kerasidou, A., P. Kingori, and H. Legido-Quigley, "you have to keep fighting": Maintaining healthcare services and professionalism on the frontline of austerity in Greece. International Journal for Equity in Health, 2016. 15(1).
  11. Kerasidou, A. and P. Kingori, Austerity measures and the transforming role of A&E professionals in a weakening welfare system. PLoS ONE, 2019. 14(2).
  12. Ortega-Galan, A.M., R. Ortiz-Amo, E. Andina-Diaz, and M.D. Ruiz-Fernandez, The Sustainability of Public Social Services: A Qualitative Study. Sustainability, 2020. 12(9).
  13. Heras-Mosteiro, J., B. Sanz-Barbero, and L. Otero-Garcia, Health Care Austerity Measures in Times of Crisis: The Perspectives of Primary Health Care Physicians in Madrid, Spain. International journal of health services : planning, administration, evaluation, 2016. 46(2): p. 283-299.
  14. Cimas, M., P. Gullon, E. Aguilera, et al., Healthcare coverage for undocumented migrants in Spain: Regional differences after Royal Decree Law 16/2012. Health Policy, 2016. 120(4): p. 384-395.
  15. Gogishvili, M., K.R. Flórez, S.A. Costa, and T.T.K. Huang, A qualitative study on mixed experiences of discrimination and healthcare access among HIV-positive immigrants in Spain. BMC public health, 2021. 21(1): p. 385.
  16. Porthe, V., I. Vargas, B. Sanz-Barbero, et al., Changes in access to health care for immigrants in Catalonia during the economic crisis: Opinions of health professionals and immigrant users. Health Policy, 2016. 120(11): p. 1293-1303.
  17. Brall, C., P. Schröder-Bäck, R. Porz, F. Tahzib, and H. Brand, Ethics, health policy-making and the economic crisis: A qualitative interview study with European policy-makers. International Journal for Equity in Health, 2019. 18(1).
  18. Petrou, P., The Impact of Financial Crisis, Austerity Measures, and Bailout Agreement on Cypriots’ Health: The Memorandum Is Dead, Long Live the Memorandum. Value in Health Regional Issues, 2019. 19: p. 99-103.
  19. Doetsch, J., E. Pilot, P. Santana, and T. Krafft, Potential barriers in healthcare access of the elderly population influenced by the economic crisis and the troika agreement: A qualitative case study in Lisbon, Portugal. International Journal for Equity in Health, 2017. 16(1).
  20. Poduval, S., N. Howard, L. Jones, et al., Experiences Among Undocumented Migrants Accessing Primary Care in the United Kingdom: A Qualitative Study. International Journal of Health Services, 2015. 45(2): p. 320-333.
  21. Alvarez-Galvez, J., V. Suarez-Lledo, G. Martinez-Cousinou, E. Muniategui-Azkona, and A. Gonzalez-Portillo, The impact of financial crisis and austerity policies in Andalusia, Spain: Disentangling the mechanisms of social inequalities in health through the perceptions and experiences of experts and the general population. International Journal for Equity in Health, 2019. 18(1).
  22. Balushi, M.A., How internal transparency impacts organizational resilience. International Journal of Quality & Reliability …. 2020: emerald.com.
  23. Griffiths, D., Resilience and transparency in social systems. Kybernetes, 2019.
  24. Edwards, I., C. Delany, A. Townsend, and ... Moral agency as enacted justice: a clinical and ethical decision-making framework for responding to health inequities and social injustice. Physical …, 2011.
  25. Ong, C., Moral distress, moral equilibrium and the moral equilibrium framework: health professionals' well-being in the face of daily challenges to moral values and integrity. 2020: minerva-access.unimelb.edu.au.
  26. Khokhar, M., Stress, Resilience and Moral Distress among Health Care Providers During COVID-19 Pandemic. esculapio.pk. 2021.
  27. Willis, M., Moral decisions, moral distress, and the psychological health of nurses. 2015: researchgate.net.
  28. Shukla, S. and J. McCoyd, HIV Health Care Providers as Street-Level Bureaucrats: Unreflective Discourses and Implications for Women's Health and Well-Being. Ethics and Social Welfare, 2019.
  29. Nolan, A., S. Barry, S. Burke, and S. Thomas, The impact of the financial crisis on the health system and health in Ireland. 2014: Economic and Social Research Institute.
  30. Nunes, A.M., D.C. Ferreira, and A.C. Fernandes, Financial Crisis in Portugal: Effects in the Health Care Sector. International Journal of Health Services, 2019. 49(2): p. 237-259.
  31. Sakellarides, C., L. Castelo-Branco, P. Barbosa, and H. Azevedo, The impact of the financial crisis on the health system and health in Portugal. Copenhagen: World Health Organization, 2014.
  32. Laschinger, H., J. Finegan, J. Shamian, and P. Wilk, Workplace empowerment as a predictor of nurse burnout in restructured healthcare settings. Longwoods Review, 2003.
  33. Vélez, C., M. Wilson, J. Lavis, J. Abelson, and ... A framework for explaining the role of values in health policy decision-making in Latin America: a critical interpretive synthesis. Health research policy …. 2020: Springer.
  34. Taylor, M. and K. Bentley, Professional dissonance: Colliding values and job tasks in mental health practice. Community mental health journal, 2005.
  35. Moussa, M., Why Do Street-Level Bureaucrats Risk Themselves for Others? The Case of Public Health Care Workers in Egypt. 2022: fount.aucegypt.edu.
  36. Virtanen, P., I. Laitinen, and J. Stenvall, Street-level bureaucrats as strategy shapers in social and health service delivery: Empirical evidence from six countries. International Social Work, 2018.
  37. Spilg, E., C. Rushton, J. Phillips, T. Kendzerska, and ... The new frontline: exploring the links between moral distress, moral resilience and mental health in healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. BMC psychiatry. 2022: Springer.
  38. Virani, S., Moral distress amid COVID-19: A frontline emergency nurse’s perspective. Nursing, 51 (12), 39-43. doi: 10.1097/01.NURSE.0000800072.35132.c1, 2021. 15(12): p. 39-43.
  39. Crowther, D., Organisational theory / David Crowther, Miriam Green. 2004. p. 0-0.
  40. Sharifi, M., A.A. Asadi-Pooya, and R.S. Mousavi-Roknabadi, Burnout among Healthcare Providers of COVID-19; a Systematic Review of Epidemiology and Recommendations. Archives of academic emergency medicine, 2020. 9(1): p. e7-e7.
  41. Gualano, M.R., T. Sinigaglia, G. Lo Moro, et al., The Burden of Burnout among Healthcare Professionals of Intensive Care Units and Emergency Departments during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2021. 18(15): p. 8172.
  42. Cacchione, P.Z., Moral Distress in the Midst of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Clinical Nursing Research, 2020. 29(4): p. 215-216.
  43. Littlejohns, P., K. Chalkidou, A. Culyer, and ... National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, social values and healthcare priority setting. Journal of the Royal …, 2019.
  44. Christian, G., A. Thomas, E. Erik, and H. Andreas, Providing healthcare through ?value shops?: impact on professional fulfilment for physicians and nurses. 2020. 25(2): p. 127-136.

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 22 November 2022
  • Receive Date: 27 May 2022
  • Revise Date: 22 September 2022
  • Accept Date: 19 November 2022
  • First Publish Date: 22 November 2022