The Experiences of Strategic Purchasing of Healthcare in Nine Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Qualitative Review

Document Type : Review Article

Authors

1 Centre for Health Policy, School of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa

2 Department of Public Policy and Management, SD Dombo University of Business and Integrated Development Studies, Wa, Ghana

3 School of Community Health, Charles Sturt University, Orange, NSW, Australia

4 Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK

5 Department of International Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD, USA

6 School of Health Systems and Public Health, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa

7 Consortium for Advanced Research Training in Africa (CARTA), Nairobi, Kenya

8 School of Public Health, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa

Abstract

Background 
Efforts to move towards universal health coverage (UHC) aim to rebalance health financing in ways that increase efficiency, equity, and quality. Resource constraints require a shift from passive to strategic purchasing (SP). In this paper, we report on the experiences of SP in public sector health insurance schemes in nine middle-income countries to understand what extent SP has been established, the challenges and facilitators, and how it is helping countries achieve their UHC goals.

Methods 
We conducted a systematic search to identify papers on SP. Nine countries were selected for case study analysis. We extracted data from 129 articles. We used a common framework to compare the purchasing arrangements and key features in the different schemes. The evidence was synthesised qualitatively.

Results 
Five countries had health technology assessment (HTA) units to research what services to buy. Most schemes had reimbursement mechanisms that enabled some degree of cost control. However, we found evidenced-based changes to the reimbursement mechanisms only in Thailand and China. All countries have some form of mechanism for accreditation of health facilities, although there was considerable variation in what is done. All countries had some strategy for monitoring claims, but they vary in complexity and the extent of implementation; three countries have implemented e-claim processing enabling a greater level of monitoring. Only four countries had independent governance structures to provide oversight. We found delayed reimbursement (six countries), failure to provide services in the benefits package (four countries), and high out-of-pocket (OOP) payments in all countries except Thailand and Indonesia, suggesting the schemes were failing their members.

Conclusion 
We recommend investment in purchaser and research capacity and a focus on strong governance, including regular engagement between the purchaser, provider and citizens, to build trusting relationships to leverage the potential of SP more fully, and expand financial protection and progress towards UHC.

Keywords


  1. World Health Organization (WHO). The World Health Report 2000: Health Systems: Improving Performance. WHO; 2000.
  2. Kutzin J. Health financing for universal coverage and health system performance: concepts and implications for policy. Bull World Health Organ. 2013;91(8):602-611. doi:2471/blt.12.113985
  3. McIntyre D. Learning from Experience: Health Care Financing in Low-and Middle-Income Countries. Geneva: Global Forum for Health Research; 2007.
  4. World Health Organization (WHO). Governance for Strategic Purchasing: An Analytical Framework to Guide a Country Assessment. WHO; 2019.
  5. Honda A, Hanson K, Tangcharoensathien V, Huntington D, McIntyre D. Strategic purchasing’–definition and analytical framework used in the multi-country study. In: Strategic Purchasing in China, Indonesia and the Philippines. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2016. p. 2.
  6. Kutzin J, Sparkes SP. Health systems strengthening, universal health coverage, health security and resilience. Bull World Health Organ. 2016;94(1):2. doi:2471/blt.15.165050
  7. What is strategic purchasing for health? Resarchonline website. https://researchonline.lshtm.ac.uk/id/eprint/2760470/2/Purchasing%20brief.pdf. Published October 2014.
  8. Tangcharoensathien V, Limwattananon S, Patcharanarumol W, Thammatacharee J, Jongudomsuk P, Sirilak S. Achieving universal health coverage goals in Thailand: the vital role of strategic purchasing. Health Policy Plan. 2015;30(9):1152-1161. doi:1093/heapol/czu120
  9. Klasa K, Greer SL, van Ginneken E. Strategic purchasing in practice: comparing ten European countries. Health Policy. 2018;122(5):457-472. doi:1016/j.healthpol.2018.01.014
  10. Hamadeh N, Van Rompaey C, Metreau E. New World Bank Country Classifications by Income Level: 2021-2022. World Bank Blogs; 2021.
  11. Serajuddin U, Hamadeh N. New World Bank Country Classifications by Income Level: 2020-2021. World Bank Blogs; 2020. https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/new-world-bank-country-classifications-income-level-2020-2021. Accessed February 11, 2021.
  12. Kien VD, Van Minh H, Giang KB, Dao A, Tuan LT, Ng N. Socioeconomic inequalities in catastrophic health expenditure and impoverishment associated with non-communicable diseases in urban Hanoi, Vietnam. Int J Equity Health. 2016;15(1):169. doi:1186/s12939-016-0460-3
  13. Nguyen H, Ivers R, Jan S, Pham C. Analysis of out-of-pocket costs associated with hospitalised injuries in Vietnam. BMJ Glob Health. 2017;2(1):e000082. doi:1136/bmjgh-2016-000082
  14. Onwujekwe O, Hanson K, Ichoku H, Uzochukwu B. Financing incidence analysis of household out-of-pocket spending for healthcare: getting more health for money in Nigeria? Int J Health Plann Manage. 2014;29(2):e174-185. doi:1002/hpm.2166
  15. Patcharanarumol W, Panichkriangkrai W, Sommanuttaweechai A, Hanson K, Wanwong Y, Tangcharoensathien V. Strategic purchasing and health system efficiency: a comparison of two financing schemes in Thailand. PLoS One. 2018;13(4):e0195179. doi:1371/journal.pone.0195179
  16. World Health Organization (WHO). The World Health Report 2003: Shaping the Future. WHO; 2003.
  17. McIntyre D, Meheus F, Røttingen JA. What level of domestic government health expenditure should we aspire to for universal health coverage? Health Econ Policy Law. 2017;12(2):125-137. doi:1017/s1744133116000414
  18. World Bank. World Development Indicators. DataBank; 2021.
  19. Doshmangir L, Moshiri E, Mostafavi H, Alipouri Sakha M, Assan A. Policy analysis of the Iranian Health Transformation Plan in primary healthcare. BMC Health Serv Res. 2019;19(1):670. doi:1186/s12913-019-4505-3
  20. Tangcharoensathien V, Patcharanarumol W, Ir P, et al. Health-financing reforms in southeast Asia: challenges in achieving universal coverage. Lancet. 2011;377(9768):863-873. doi:1016/s0140-6736(10)61890-9
  21. Gu E, Page-Jarrett I. The top-level design of social health insurance reforms in China: towards universal coverage, improved benefit design, and smart payment methods. J Chin Gov. 2018;3(3):331-350. doi:1080/23812346.2018.1491112
  22. Fusheini A, Marnoch G, Gray AM. Stakeholders perspectives on the success drivers in Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme - identifying policy translation issues. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2017;6(5):273-283. doi:15171/ijhpm.2016.133
  23. Amu H, Dickson KS, Kumi-Kyereme A, Darteh EKM. Understanding variations in health insurance coverage in Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, and Tanzania: evidence from demographic and health surveys. PLoS One. 2018;13(8):e0201833. doi:1371/journal.pone.0201833
  24. Chuma J, Maina T, Ataguba J. Does the distribution of health care benefits in Kenya meet the principles of universal coverage? BMC Public Health. 2012;12:20. doi:1186/1471-2458-12-20
  25. Aregbeshola BS, Khan SM. Determinants of catastrophic health expenditure in Nigeria. Eur J Health Econ. 2018;19(4):521-532. doi:1007/s10198-017-0899-1
  26. Kabia E, Mbau R, Oyando R, et al. "We are called the et cetera": experiences of the poor with health financing reforms that target them in Kenya. Int J Equity Health. 2019;18(1):98. doi:1186/s12939-019-1006-2
  27. Kumar MB, Taegtmeyer M, Madan J, et al. How do decision-makers use evidence in community health policy and financing decisions? A qualitative study and conceptual framework in four African countries. Health Policy Plan. 2020;35(7):799-809. doi:1093/heapol/czaa027
  28. Agustina R, Dartanto T, Sitompul R, et al. Universal health coverage in Indonesia: concept, progress, and challenges. Lancet. 2019;393(10166):75-102. doi:1016/s0140-6736(18)31647-7
  29. Dartanto T, Halimatussadiah A, Rezki JF, et al. Why do informal sector workers not pay the premium regularly? Evidence from the National Health Insurance System in Indonesia. Appl Health Econ Health Policy. 2020;18(1):81-96. doi:1007/s40258-019-00518-y
  30. Ezeoke OP, Onwujekwe OE, Uzochukwu BS. Towards universal coverage: examining costs of illness, payment, and coping strategies to different population groups in southeast Nigeria. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2012;86(1):52-57. doi:4269/ajtmh.2012.11-0090
  31. Ibe O, Honda A, Etiaba E, Ezumah N, Hanson K, Onwujekwe O. Do beneficiaries' views matter in healthcare purchasing decisions? Experiences from the Nigerian tax-funded health system and the formal sector social health insurance program of the National Health Insurance Scheme. Int J Equity Health. 2017;16(1):216. doi:1186/s12939-017-0711-y
  32. Amu H, Dickson KS, Kumi-Kyereme A, Darteh EKM. Understanding variations in health insurance coverage in Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, and Tanzania: Evidence from demographic and health surveys. PLoS One. 2018;13(8):e0201833. doi:1371/journal.pone.0201833
  33. Barimah KB, Mensah J. Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme: insights from members, administrators and health care providers. J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2013;24(3):1378-1390. doi:1353/hpu.2013.0144
  34. Etiaba E, Onwujekwe O, Honda A, Ibe O, Uzochukwu B, Hanson K. Strategic purchasing for universal health coverage: examining the purchaser-provider relationship within a social health insurance scheme in Nigeria. BMJ Glob Health. 2018;3(5):e000917. doi:1136/bmjgh-2018-000917
  35. Maharani A, Tampubolon G. Does corporatisation improve organisational commitment? Evidence from public hospitals in Indonesia. Int J Hum Resour Manag. 2018;29(13):1999-2026. doi:1080/09585192.2016.1239121
  36. Meemon N, Paek SC. The impact of Thailand's universal coverage scheme on household catastrophic health expenditure. Asia-Pac Soc Sci Rev. 2019;19(3):144-154.
  37. Dong W, Zwi AB, Bai R, Shen C, Gao J. Benefit of China's social health insurance schemes: trend analysis and associated factors since health reform. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021;18(11):5672. doi:3390/ijerph18115672
  38. Mbau R, Kabia E, Honda A, Hanson K, Barasa E. Examining purchasing reforms towards universal health coverage by the National Hospital Insurance Fund in Kenya. Int J Equity Health. 2020;19(1):19. doi:1186/s12939-019-1116-x
  39. Ebunoha GN, Ughasoro MD, Nwakoby IC, Onwujekwe OE. Achieving financial risk protection through a national Social Health Insurance Programme in Nigeria: perspectives of enrollees and healthcare providers. Int J Health Plann Manage. 2020;35(4):859-866. doi:1002/hpm.2949
  40. Yang L, Sun L, Wen L, et al. Financing strategies to improve essential public health equalization and its effects in China. Int J Equity Health. 2016;15(1):194. doi:1186/s12939-016-0482-x
  41. Agyemang-Duah W, Peprah C, Peprah P. "Let's talk about money": how do poor older people finance their healthcare in rural Ghana? A qualitative study. Int J Equity Health. 2019;18(1):47. doi:1186/s12939-019-0927-0
  42. Le Tuan P, Nam VT, Dung TC, et al. Adopting Thai Diagnosis Related Group for Vietnam universal health coverage: a case of Ba Vi district hospital. Siriraj Med J. 2015;67(5):227-234.
  43. Atuoye KN, Vercillo S, Antabe R, Galaa SZ, Luginaah I. Financial sustainability versus access and quality in a challenged health system: an examination of the capitation policy debate in Ghana. Health Policy Plan. 2016;31(9):1240-1249. doi:1093/heapol/czw058
  44. Prakongsai P, Palmer N, Uay‐Trakul P, Tangcharoensathien V, Mills A. The implications of benefit package design: the impact on poor Thai households of excluding renal replacement therapy. J Int Dev. 2009;21(2):291-308. doi:1002/jid.1553
  45. Zhang H, Zhang C, Zhu S, Zhu F, Wen Y. Costs of hospitalization for chronic kidney disease in Guangzhou, China. Public Adm Policy. 2019;22(2):138-151. doi:1108/PAP-09-2019-0018
  46. Andoh-Adjei FX, Cornelissen D, Asante FA, Spaan E, van der Velden K. Does capitation payment under national health insurance affect subscribers' trust in their primary care provider? a cross-sectional survey of insurance subscribers in Ghana. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016;16(1):437. doi:1186/s12913-016-1622-0
  47. Álvarez-Hernández E, Peláez-Ballestas I, Boonen A, et al. Catastrophic health expenses and impoverishment of households of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Reumatol Clin. 2012;8(4):168-173. doi:1016/j.reuma.2012.05.002
  48. Chuma J, Maina T. Catastrophic health care spending and impoverishment in Kenya. BMC Health Serv Res. 2012;12:413. doi:1186/1472-6963-12-413
  49. Agyepong IA, Nagai RA. "We charge them; otherwise we cannot run the hospital" front line workers, clients and health financing policy implementation gaps in Ghana. Health Policy. 2011;99(3):226-233. doi:1016/j.healthpol.2010.09.018
  50. Akazili J, Welaga P, Bawah A, et al. Is Ghana's pro-poor health insurance scheme really for the poor? Evidence from Northern Ghana. BMC Health Serv Res. 2014;14:637. doi:1186/s12913-014-0637-7
  51. Le QN, Blizzard L, Si L, Giang LT, Neil AL. The evolution of social health insurance in Vietnam and its role towards achieving universal health coverage. Health Policy Open. 2020;1:100011. doi:1016/j.hpopen.2020.100011
  52. Adu-Gyamfi S, Brenya E, Amoah A. National Health Insurance Scheme of Ejisu-Juaben and matters arising. Int J Soc Sci Stud. 2015;3(5):40-60. doi:11114/ijsss.v3i5.962
  53. Tangcharoensathien V, Tisayaticom K, Suphanchaimat R, Vongmongkol V, Viriyathorn S, Limwattananon S. Financial risk protection of Thailand's universal health coverage: results from series of national household surveys between 1996 and 2015. Int J Equity Health. 2020;19(1):163. doi:1186/s12939-020-01273-6
  54. Tan SY, Qian J. An unintended consequence of provider payment reform: the case of capitation grants in the National Health Insurance reform of Indonesia. Int J Health Plann Manage. 2019;34(4):e1688-e1710. doi:1002/hpm.2883
  55. Zhang G, Zhang L, Wu S, Xia X, Lu L. The convergence of Chinese county government health expenditures: capitation and contribution. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016;16(1):408. doi:1186/s12913-016-1635-8
  56. Nketiah-Amponsah E, Alhassan RK, Ampaw S, Abuosi A. Subscribers' perception of quality of services provided by Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme - what are the correlates? BMC Health Serv Res. 2019;19(1):196. doi:1186/s12913-019-4023-3
  57. Gao C, Xu F, Liu GG. Payment reform and changes in health care in China. Soc Sci Med. 2014;111:10-16. doi:1016/j.socscimed.2014.03.035
  58. Odeyemi IA, Nixon J. Assessing equity in health care through the national health insurance schemes of Nigeria and Ghana: a review-based comparative analysis. Int J Equity Health. 2013;12:9. doi:1186/1475-9276-12-9
  59. Nigenda G, Wirtz VJ, González-Robledo LM, Reich MR. Evaluating the implementation of Mexico's health reform: the case of Seguro Popular. Health Syst Reform. 2015;1(3):217-228. doi:1080/23288604.2015.1031336
  60. Cashin C, Phuong NK, Shain R, Oanh TT, Thuy NT. A simple simulation model as a tool to assess alternative health care provider payment reform options in Vietnam. Glob Public Health. 2015;10 Supppl 1:S104-119. doi:1080/17441692.2014.986156
  61. Tang S, Wang L, Wang H, Chin DP. Access to and affordability of healthcare for TB patients in China: issues and challenges. Infect Dis Poverty. 2016;5:10. doi:1186/s40249-016-0096-y
  62. Jiang J, Lucas H, Long Q, Xin Y, Xiang L, Tang S. The effect of an innovative financing and payment model for tuberculosis patients on health service utilization in China: evidence from Hubei province of China. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2019;16(14):2494. doi:3390/ijerph16142494
  63. Mirabedini SA, Fazl Hashemi SME, Sarabi Asiabar A, Rezapour A, Azami-Aghdash S, Hosseini Amnab H. Out-of-pocket and informal payments in Iran's health care system: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2017;31:70. doi:14196/mjiri.31.70
  64. Kong XJ, Du Z, Zhao M, Yang Y, Qin Y. Red envelope and doctor-patient trust: report of research on national questionnaire survey of 4000 inpatients in 10 cities (VII). Med Philos Humanis Social Med Edit. 2011;32(5):34-37.
  65. Guo Y. Personal relationships with the physicians, impression on the physicians and the urban residents' residents’ behavior of sending the red envelopes. Chinese Health Service Management. 2015;2:124-126.
  66. Liu N, Bao G, He AJ. Does health insurance coverage reduce informal payments? Evidence from the "red envelopes" in China. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020;20(1):95. doi:1186/s12913-020-4955-7
  67. García-Díaz R, Sosa-Rubí SG, Serván-Mori E, Nigenda G. Welfare effects of health insurance in Mexico: the case of Seguro Popular de Salud. PLoS One. 2018;13(7):e0199876. doi:1371/journal.pone.0199876
  68. Thuong NTT, Huy TQ, Tai DA, Kien TN. Impact of health insurance on health care utilisation and out-of-pocket health expenditure in Vietnam. Biomed Res Int. 2020;2020:9065287. doi:1155/2020/9065287
  69. Duc Thanh N, Anh BTM, Thanh Hung P, Quynh Anh P, Huyen Xiem C. Impact of public health insurance on out-of-pocket health expenditures of the near-poor in Vietnam. Health Serv Insights. 2021;14:11786329211017411. doi:1177/11786329211017411
  70. Hidayat B. Out-of-Pocket Payments in the National Health Insurance of Indonesia: A First Year Review: Policy Brief. German National Library; 2015.
  71. Akweongo P, Aikins M, Wyss K, Salari P, Tediosi F. Insured clients out-of-pocket payments for health care under the National Health Insurance Scheme in Ghana. BMC Health Serv Res. 2021;21(1):440. doi:1186/s12913-021-06401-8
  72. Barasa EW, Mwaura N, Rogo K, Andrawes L. Extending voluntary health insurance to the informal sector: experiences and expectations of the informal sector in Kenya. Wellcome Open Res. 2017;2:94. doi:12688/wellcomeopenres.12656.1
  73. Ebunoha GN, Ughasoro MD, Nwakoby IC, Onwujekwe OE. Achieving financial risk protection through a national Social Health Insurance Programme in Nigeria: perspectives of enrollees and healthcare providers. Int J Health Plann Manage. 2020;35(4):859-866. doi:1002/hpm.2949
  74. Suphanchaimat R, Kantamaturapoj K, Pudpong N, Putthasri W, Mills A. Health insurance for people with citizenship problems in Thailand: a case study of policy implementation. Health Policy Plan. 2016;31(2):229-238. doi:1093/heapol/czv046
  75. Fenny AP, Asante FA, Enemark U, Hansen KS. Treatment-seeking behaviour and social health insurance in Africa: the case of Ghana under the National Health Insurance Scheme. Glob J Health Sci. 2014;7(1):296-314. doi:5539/gjhs.v7n1p296
  76. Phuong NK, Oanh TT, Phuong HT, Tien TV, Cashin C. Assessment of systems for paying health care providers in Vietnam: implications for equity, efficiency and expanding effective health coverage. Glob Public Health. 2015;10 Supppl 1:S80-94. doi:1080/17441692.2014.986154
  77. Kihuba E, Gheorghe A, Bozzani F, English M, Griffiths UK. Opportunities and challenges for implementing cost accounting systems in the Kenyan health system. Glob Health Action. 2016;9:30621. doi:3402/gha.v9.30621
  78. Munge K, Briggs AH. The progressivity of health-care financing in Kenya. Health Policy Plan. 2014;29(7):912-920. doi:1093/heapol/czt073
  79. Yip W, Fu H, Chen AT, et al. 10 years of health-care reform in China: progress and gaps in universal health coverage. Lancet. 2019;394(10204):1192-1204. doi:1016/s0140-6736(19)32136-1
  80. Zhao C, Wang C, Shen C, Wang Q. China's achievements and challenges in improving health insurance coverage. Drug Discov Ther. 2018;12(1):1-6. doi:5582/ddt.2017.01064
  81. Sunarti S, Ghozali MT, Haris F, Rahman FF, Rahman RA. Preventing fraud and deficit through the optimization of health insurance in Indonesia. Syst Rev Pharm. 2020;11(7):228-231.
  82. Zhao C, Wang C, Shen C, Wang Q. Diagnosis-related group (DRG)-based case-mix funding system, a promising alternative for fee for service payment in China. Biosci Trends. 2018;12(2):109-115. doi:5582/bst.2017.01289
  83. Hipgrave DB, Anderson I, Sato M. A rapid assessment of the political economy of health at district level, with a focus on maternal, newborn and child health, in Bangladesh, Indonesia, Nepal and the Philippines. Health Policy Plan. 2019;34(10):762-772. doi:1093/heapol/czz082
  84. Limwattananon C, Limwattananon S, Tungthong J, Sirikomon K. Association between a centrally reimbursed fee schedule policy and access to cataract surgery in the universal coverage scheme in Thailand. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2018;136(7):796-802. doi:1001/jamaophthalmol.2018.1843
  85. Hipgrave DB, Laksmono LH, Koemarasakti GM, et al. District team problem solving as an approach to district health programme planning: a review, and survey of its status in selected districts in Indonesia. Health Policy Plan. 2018;33(4):555-563. doi:1093/heapol/czy007
  86. Kazungu JS, Barasa EW. Examining levels, distribution and correlates of health insurance coverage in Kenya. Trop Med Int Health. 2017;22(9):1175-1185. doi:1111/tmi.12912
  87. Andoh-Adjei FX, Spaan E, Asante FA, Mensah SA, van der Velden K. A narrative synthesis of illustrative evidence on effects of capitation payment for primary care: lessons for Ghana and other low/middle-income countries. Ghana Med J. 2016;50(4):207-219. doi:4314/gmj.v50i4.3
  88. Doshmangir L, Bazyar M, Najafi B, Haghparast-Bidgoli H. Health financing consequences of implementing health transformation plan in Iran: achievements and challenges. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2019;8(6):384-386. doi:15171/ijhpm.2019.18
  89. Martínez G. [Resource allocation in the Seguro Popular program: analysis and recommendations]. Salud Publica Mex. 2016;58(5):577-583. doi:21149/spm.v58i5.8248
  90. Mathauer I, Behrendt T. State budget transfers to Health Insurance to expand coverage to people outside formal sector work in Latin America. BMC Health Serv Res. 2017;17(1):145. doi:1186/s12913-017-2004-y
  91. González Block M, Reyes Morales H, Hurtado LC, Balandrán A, Méndez E. Mexico: health system review. Health Syst Transit. 2020;22(2):1-222.
  92. Gómez-Dantés O, Frenk J. Health technology assessment in Mexico. Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2009;25 Suppl 1:270-275. doi:1017/s0266462309090746
  93. Lee HY, Nguyen TT, Park S, Hoang VM, Kim WH. Health technology assessment development in Vietnam: a qualitative study of current progress, barriers, facilitators, and future strategies. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021;18(16):8846. doi:3390/ijerph18168846
  94. MacQuilkan K, Baker P, Downey L, et al. Strengthening health technology assessment systems in the global south: a comparative analysis of the HTA journeys of China, India and South Africa. Glob Health Action. 2018;11(1):1527556. doi:1080/16549716.2018.1527556
  95. Alinia C, Davoodi Lahijan J. Moving toward universal health coverage: four decades of experience from the Iranian health system. Clinicoecon Outcomes Res. 2019;11:651-657. doi:2147/ceor.s219802
  96. Ekman B, Liem NT, Duc HA, Axelson H. Health insurance reform in Vietnam: a review of recent developments and future challenges. Health Policy Plan. 2008;23(4):252-263. doi:1093/heapol/czn009
  97. Giménez V, Keith JR, Prior D. Do healthcare financing systems influence hospital efficiency? A metafrontier approach for the case of Mexico. Health Care Manag Sci. 2019;22(3):549-559. doi:1007/s10729-019-9467-9
  98. Li Y, Ying C, Sufang G, Brant P, Bin L, Hipgrave D. Evaluation, in three provinces, of the introduction and impact of China's National Essential Medicines Scheme. Bull World Health Organ. 2013;91(3):184-194. doi:2471/blt.11.097998
  99. Maharani A, Femina D, Tampubolon G. Decentralization in Indonesia: lessons from cost recovery rate of district hospitals. Health Policy Plan. 2015;30(6):718-727. doi:1093/heapol/czu049
  100. Mitra S, Palmer M, Mont D, Groce N. Can households cope with health shocks in Vietnam? Health Econ. 2016;25(7):888-907. doi:1002/hec.3196
  101. Palmer MG. Inequalities in universal health coverage: evidence from Vietnam. World Dev. 2014;64:384-394. doi:1016/j.worlddev.2014.06.008
  102. González Block M, Reyes H, Cahuana Hurtado L, Balandrán A, Méndez E. Mexico’s health system: in longstanding pursuit of universal coverage and integration. Eur J Public Health. 2020;30(Suppl 5):ckaa165.782. doi:1093/eurpub/ckaa165.782
  103. Tangcharoensathien V, Limwattananon S, Suphanchaimat R, Patcharanarumol W, Sawaengdee K, Putthasri W. Health workforce contributions to health system development: a platform for universal health coverage. Bull World Health Organ. 2013;91(11):874-880. doi:2471/blt.13.120774
  104. Erniaty E, Harun H. Understanding the impacts of NPM and proposed solutions to the healthcare system reforms in Indonesia: the case of BPJS. Health Policy Plan. 2020;35(3):346-353. doi:1093/heapol/czz165
  105. Kazungu J, Kabia E, Munge K, Barasa E. Assessing the progress and gaps in strategic health purchasing in Kenya. Wellcome Open Res. 2021;6:81. doi:12688/wellcomeopenres.16606.1
  106. Mukhlisa MN, Pujiyanto P. The effect of health insurance on institutional delivery in Indonesia. Kesmas. 2018;12(3):148-152. doi:21109/kesmas.v12i3.1099
  107. Pisani E, Olivier Kok M, Nugroho K. Indonesia's road to universal health coverage: a political journey. Health Policy Plan. 2017;32(2):267-276. doi:1093/heapol/czw120
  108. Obikeze E, Onwujekwe O. The roles of health maintenance organizations in the implementation of a social health insurance scheme in Enugu, Southeast Nigeria: a mixed-method investigation. Int J Equity Health. 2020;19(1):33. doi:1186/s12939-020-1146-4
  109. Tangcharoensathien V, Suphanchaimat R, Thammatacharee N, Patcharanarumol W. Thailand's universal health coverage scheme. Econ Polit Wkly. 2012;47(8):53-57.
  110. Liu J. Healthcare Quality and HIT-International Standards, China Practices. CRC Press; 2019.
  111. Kalantari AR, Jafari Sirizi M, Mehrolhassani MH, Dehnavieh R. Challenges of implementation: strategic purchasing in Iran Health Insurance Organization. Int J Health Plann Manage. 2019;34(1):e875-e884. doi:1002/hpm.2704
  112. Smits H, Supachutikul A, Mate KS. Hospital accreditation: lessons from low- and middle-income countries. Global Health. 2014;10:65. doi:1186/s12992-014-0065-9
  113. Suchman L. Accrediting private providers with National Health Insurance to better serve low-income populations in Kenya and Ghana: a qualitative study. Int J Equity Health. 2018;17(1):179. doi:1186/s12939-018-0893-y
  114. Sieverding M, Onyango C, Suchman L. Private healthcare provider experiences with social health insurance schemes: findings from a qualitative study in Ghana and Kenya. PLoS One. 2018;13(2):e0192973. doi:1371/journal.pone.0192973
  115. Luo S, Zhang K, Li B. Medical informatics in China: healthcare IT trends, academic and research developments. Yearb Med Inform. 2010;19(1):109-115. doi:1055/s-0038-1638700
  116. Youthao S, Amornsiriphong S. One Health information management: health system reforms to support social well-being in Thailand. Int J One Health. 2021;7(1):96-103.
  117. Abdulai AF, Adam F. Health providers' readiness for electronic health records adoption: a cross-sectional study of two hospitals in northern Ghana. PLoS One. 2020;15(6):e0231569. doi:1371/journal.pone.0231569
  118. Li C, Yu X, Butler JR, Yiengprugsawan V, Yu M. Moving towards universal health insurance in China: performance, issues and lessons from Thailand. Soc Sci Med. 2011;73(3):359-366. doi:1016/j.socscimed.2011.06.002
  119. González-Block M, Alarcón Irigoyen J, Figueroa Lara A, Ibarra Espinosa I, Cortés Llamas N. [The strategic purchasing of health services: a big opportunity for the National Universal Health System]. Gac Med Mex. 2015;151(2):278-280. [Spanish].
  120. Tan SY. Bureaucratic autonomy and policy capacity in the implementation of capitation payment systems in primary healthcare: comparative case studies of three districts in Central Java, Indonesia. J Asian Public Policy. 2019;12(3):330-350. doi:1080/17516234.2018.1459150
  121. Khoiri A, Hidayat W, Chalidyanto D, Suhariadi F. Potential of hospital fraud in the Indonesia national health insurance era (a descriptive phenomenological research). Indian J Forensic Med Toxicol. 2020;14(3):1132-1136. doi:37506/ijfmt.v14i3.10527
  122. Doshmangir L, Sajadi HS, Ghiasipour M, Aboutorabi A, Gordeev VS. Informal payments for inpatient health care in post-health transformation plan period: evidence from Iran. BMC Public Health. 2020;20(1):539. doi:1186/s12889-020-8432-3
  123. Munge K, Mulupi S, Barasa EW, Chuma J. A critical analysis of purchasing arrangements in Kenya: the case of the National Hospital Insurance Fund. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2018;7(3):244-254. doi:15171/ijhpm.2017.81
  124. Lawan UM, Iliyasu Z, Daso AM. Challenges to the scale-up of the Nigerian National Health Insurance Scheme: public knowledge and opinions in urban Kano, Nigeria. Ann Trop Med Public Health. 2012;5(1):34-39. doi:4103/1755-6783.92878
  125. Hariyanto H, Denison T, Stillman L. Understanding Health Information System Implementation in an Indonesian Primary Health Centre: A Sociotechnical Perspective. 2018. https://aisel.aisnet.org/pacis2018/219.
  126. Aikins M, Tabong PT, Salari P, Tediosi F, Asenso-Boadi FM, Akweongo P. Positioning the National Health Insurance for financial sustainability and universal health coverage in Ghana: a qualitative study among key stakeholders. PLoS One. 2021;16(6):e0253109. doi:1371/journal.pone.0253109
  127. Nsiah-Boateng E, Asenso-Boadi F, Dsane-Selby L, et al. Reducing medical claims cost to Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme: a cross-sectional comparative assessment of the paper- and electronic-based claims reviews. BMC Health Serv Res. 2017;17(1):115. doi:1186/s12913-017-2054-1
  128. Joudaki H, Rashidian A, Minaei-Bidgoli B, et al. Improving fraud and abuse detection in general physician claims: a data mining study. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2015;5(3):165-172. doi:15171/ijhpm.2015.196
  129. Sajadi HS, Ehsani-Chimeh E, Majdzadeh R. Universal health coverage in Iran: where we stand and how we can move forward. Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2019;33:9. doi:34171/mjiri.33.9
  130. Chemor Ruiz A, Ratsch AEO, Alamilla Martínez GA. Mexico's Seguro Popular: achievements and challenges. Health Syst Reform. 2018;4(3):194-202. doi:1080/23288604.2018.1488505
  131. Ehsani-Chimeh E, Sajadi HS, Majdzadeh R. Iran towards universal health coverage: the role of human resources for health. Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2018;32:100. doi:14196/mjiri.32.100
  132. Akazili J, Gyapong J, McIntyre D. Who pays for health care in Ghana? Int J Equity Health. 2011;10:26. doi:1186/1475-9276-10-26
  133. World Health Organization (WHO). Designing Health Financing Systems to Reduce Catastrophic Health Expenditure. WHO; 2005.
  134. Ghoddoosi-Nejad J, Jannati A, Doshmangir L, Arab-Zozani M, Imani A. Stewardship as a fundamental challenge in strategic purchasing of health services: a case study of Iran. Value Health Reg Issues. 2019;18:54-58. doi:1016/j.vhri.2018.06.005
  135. Yarney L, Buabeng T, Baidoo D, Bawole JN. Operationalization of the Ghanaian patients' charter in a peri-urban public hospital: voices of healthcare workers and patients. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2016;5(9):525-533. doi:15171/ijhpm.2016.42
  136. Halvorsen K, Dihle A, Hansen C, et al. Empowerment in healthcare: a thematic synthesis and critical discussion of concept analyses of empowerment. Patient Educ Couns. 2020;103(7):1263-1271. doi:1016/j.pec.2020.02.017
  137. Liu Y, Saltman RB. Establishing appropriate agency relationships for providers in China. Inquiry. 2019;56:46958019872348. doi:1177/0046958019872348
  138. Sanderson J, Lonsdale C, Mannion R. What's needed to develop strategic purchasing in healthcare? Policy lessons from a realist review. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2019;8(1):4-17. doi:15171/ijhpm.2018.93
  139. Witter S, Bertone MP, Namakula J, et al. (How) does RBF strengthen strategic purchasing of health care? Comparing the experience of Uganda, Zimbabwe and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Glob Health Res Policy. 2019;4:3. doi:1186/s41256-019-0094-2
  140. Paul E, Brown GW, Ridde V. Misunderstandings and ambiguities in strategic purchasing in low- and middle-income countries. Int J Health Plann Manage. 2020;35(5):1001-1008. doi:1002/hpm.3019
  • Receive Date: 26 April 2022
  • Revise Date: 18 February 2023
  • Accept Date: 18 October 2023
  • First Publish Date: 21 October 2023