Utility of the Right to Health for Addressing Skilled Health Worker Shortages in Low- and Middle-Income Countries

Document Type : Review Article

Authors

1 The George Institute for Global Health, Faculty of Medicine, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia

2 School of Population Health, Faculty of Medicine, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia

3 School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia

4 Discipline of Paediatrics, School of Women and Children’s Health, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia

5 Australian Human Rights Institute, Faculty of Law, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia

Abstract

Background 
As a fundamental human right, the right to health (RTH) can influence state actors' behaviour towards health inequities. Human rights advocates have invoked the RTH in a collective demand for improved access to essential medicines in low-and-middle-income countries (LMICs). Similarly, scholars have used the RTH as a framework for analysing health problems. However, its utility for addressing skilled health worker (SHW) shortages in LMICs has been understudied. Realising that SHW shortages occur due to existing push-and-pull factors within and between LMICs and High-Countries (HICs), we sought to answer the question: "how, why, and under what circumstance does the RTH offer utility for addressing SHW shortages in LMICs?"

Methods 
We conducted a realist synthesis of evidence identified through a systematic search of peerreviewed articles in Embase, Global Health, Medline (Ovid), ProQuest – Health & Medical databases, Scopus (Elsevier), Web of Science (Clarivate), CINAHL (EBSCO), APAIS-Health, Health Systems Evidence and PDQ-EVIDENCE; as well as grey literature from Google Scholar.

Results 
We found that the RTH offers utility for addressing SHW shortages in LMICs through HIC state actors' concerns for their countries' reputational risk, recognition of their obligation to support health workforce strengthening in LMICs, and concerns for the cost implication. State actors in LMICs will respond to adopt programs inspired by the RTH when they are convinced that it offers tangible national benefits and are not overly burdened with ensuring its success. The socio-economic and institutional factors that constrain state actors' response include financial cost and sustainability of rights'-based options.

Conclusions 
State and non-state actors can use the RTH as a resource for promoting collective action towards addressing SHW shortages in LMICs. It can also inform negotiations between state actors in LMICs and their HIC counterparts.

Keywords


  1. United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. The right to the highest attainable standard of health. Geneva: Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights; 2008.
  2. Hammonds R, Ooms G, Vandenhole W. Under the (legal) radar screen: global health initiatives and international human rights obligations. BMC International Health and Human Rights. 2012;12(31).
  3. United Nations Committee on Economic Social and Cultural Rights. CESCR General Comment No. 14: The Right to the Highest Attainable Standard of Health (Art. 12)

2000.

  1. Backman G, Hunt P, Khosla R, et al. Health systems and the right to health: an assessment of 194 countries. The Lancet. 2008;372(9655):2047-2085. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(08)61781-x
  2. Fidler DP. Fighting the axis of illness: HIV/AIDS, human rights, and US foreign policy. Harv. Hum. Rts. J. 2004;17:99.
  3. Coggon J, Gola S. Global health and international community: ethical, political and regulatory challenges: A&C Black; 2013.
  4. Jonathan M. Mann, Lawrence Gostin, Sofia Gruskin, Troyen Brennan, Zita Lazzarini, Fineberg HV. Health and Human Rights. Health and Human Rights 1994;1:6-23.
  5. World Health Organization. Increasing access to health workers in remote and rural areas through improved retention: global policy recommendations. Geneva: WHO Press; 2010: http://www.who.int/hrh/retention/guidelines/en/index.html. Accessed 17th July, 2019.
  6. Bautista EB. Reattraction of needed skills to developing countries of origin. Int Migr. 1986;24(1):191-195.
  7. Jenkins R, Kydd R, Mullen P, et al. International migration of doctors, and its impact on availability of psychiatrists in low and middle income countries. PLoS One. 2010;5(2):e9049. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0009049
  8. Naicker S, Plange-Rhule J, Tutt RC, Eastwood JB. Shortage of healthcare workers in developing countries--Africa. Ethn Dis. 2009;19(1 Suppl 1):S1-60-64.
  9. Nair M, Webster P. Health professionals' migration in emerging market economies: patterns, causes and possible solutions. J Public Health (Oxf). 2013;35(1):157-163. doi:10.1093/pubmed/fds087
  10. Song S. Political Theories of Migration. Annual Review of Political Science. 2018;21(1):385-402. doi:10.1146/annurev-polisci-082317-093019
  11. Zubaran C. The international migration of health care professionals. Australas Psychiatry. 2012;20(6):512-517. doi:10.1177/1039856212467381
  12. Pawson R. The Promise of Systematic Review. In: Pawson R, ed. Evidence-Based Policy: A Realist Perspective United Kingdom: SAGE Publications. ; 2006:1-16.
  13. Pawson R. Realist Methodology: The Building Blocks of Evidence. In: Pawson R, ed. Evidence-Based Policy: A Realist Perspective United Kingdom: SAGE Publications. ; 2006:35-39.
  14. Pawson R. Realist Synthesis: New Protocols for Systematic Review. In: Pawson R, ed. Evidence-based Policy: A Realist Perspective. United Kingdom: SAGE Publications, Ltd. ; 2006:73-104.
  15. World Health Organization. The World Health Report 2006 -Working together for health. Geneva: WHO; 2006: https://www.who.int/whr/2006/whr06_en.pdf?ua=1.
  16. Jagosh J, Macaulay A, Pluye P, et al. Uncovering the Benefits of Participatory Research. . Milbank Quarterly. 2012;90,(2):311–346.
  17. Lawson T. Economic Science Without Experimentation Economics and Reality Vol 9. London: Psychology Press; 1997:208.
  18. Pawson R. Digging for Nuggets: How ‘Bad’ Research Can Yield ‘Good’ Evidence. International Journal of Social Research Methodology. 2006;9(2):127-142. doi:10.1080/13645570600595314
  19. Danermark B, Ekstro¨ m M, Jakobsen L, JC. K. Explaining Society: Critical Realism in the Social Sciences. . London: Routledge.2002.
  20. Abimbola S, Baatiema L, Bigdeli M. The impacts of decentralization on health system equity, efficiency and resilience: a realist synthesis of the evidence. Health Policy Plan. 2019;34(8):605-617. doi:10.1093/heapol/czz055
  21. Jagosh J. Retroductive theorizing in Pawson and Tilley's applied scientific realism. Journal of Critical Realism. 2020;19(2):121-130. doi:10.1080/14767430.2020.1723301
  22. Wong G, Greenhalgh T, Westhorp G, Buckingham J, Pawson R. RAMESES publication standards: realist syntheses. . BMC Med 2013;11(21). doi:https://doi.org/10.1186/1741-7015-11-21
  23. Abuagla A, Badr E. Challenges to implementation of the WHO Global Code of Practice on International Recruitment of Health Personnel: the case of Sudan. Human Resources for Health [Electronic Resource]. 2016;14(Suppl 1):30.
  24. Dovlo D. The Brain Drain and Retention of Health Professionals in Africa. Improving Tertiary Education in Sub-Saharan Africa: Things That Work! . Accra2003.
  25. Sato C. International Migration of Nurses and Human Resources for Health Policy: The Case of South Africa. Vol 11: Afrasian Research Centre, Ryukoku University; 2012:1-26.
  26. Connell J, Stilwell B. Merchants of Medical Care: Recruiting Agencies in the Global Health Care Chain. Merchants of Labour: International Institute for Labour Studies; 2006.
  27. Edge JS, Hoffman SJ. Empirical impact evaluation of the WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel in Australia, Canada, UK and USA. Global Health. 2013;9:60. doi:10.1186/1744-8603-9-60
  28. Plotnikova EV. Cross-border mobility of health professionals: contesting patients' right to health. Social Science & Medicine. 2012;74(1):20-27.
  29. Bevan S. Britain accused of ignoring nurse-recruitment ban. Lancet. 2005;366(9501):1915-1916. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736%2805%2967772-0
  30. Willetts A, Martineau T. Ethical international recruitment of health professionals: Will codes of practice protect developing country health systems?2006: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.295.9618&rep=rep1&type=pdf.
  31. Dauphinee WD. Physician migration to and from Canada: the challenge of finding the ethical and political balance between the individual's right to mobility and recruitment to underserved communities. Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions. 2005;25(1):22-29.
  32. Adhikari R, Grigulis A. Through the back door: nurse migration to the UK from Malawi and Nepal, a policy critique. Health Policy & Planning. 2014;29(2):237-245.
  33. Blacklock C, Heneghan C, Mant D, Ward AMJHRfH. Effect of UK policy on medical migration: a time series analysis of physician registration data. 2012;10(1):35. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-10-35
  34. Buchan J. International recruitment of nurses: United Kingdom case study 2002: https://eresearch.qmu.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/20.500.12289/18/JBreport.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
  35. Buchan J, McPake B, Mensah K, Rae G. Does a code make a difference--assessing the English code of practice on international recruitment. Hum Resour Health. 2009;7:33. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-7-33
  36. Squires A, Ojemeni MT, Jones S. Exploring longitudinal shifts in international nurse migration to the United States between 2003 and 2013 through a random effects panel data analysis. Hum Resour Health. 2016;14(Suppl 1):21. doi:10.1186/s12960-016-0118-7
  37. Tankwanchi AS, Hagopian A, Vermund SH. International migration of health labour: Monitoring the two-way flow of physicians in South Africa. BMJ Global Health. 2019;4(5). doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2019-001566
  38. Herfs PG. Aspects of medical migration with particular reference to the United Kingdom and the Netherlands. Human Resources for Health [Electronic Resource]. 2014;12(59):14.
  39. Tankwanchi ABS, Vermund SH, Perkins DD. Monitoring Sub-Saharan African Physician Migration and Recruitment Post-Adoption of the WHO Code of Practice: Temporal and Geographic Patterns in the United States. PLOS ONE. 2015;10(4):e0124734. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0124734
  40. Peñaloza B, Pantoja T, Bastías G, Herrera CA, Rada G. Interventions to reduce emigration of health care professionals from low‐ and middle‐income countries. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2011(9). doi:10.1002/14651858.CD007673.pub2
  41. Kober K. Scaling-up access to antiretroviral treatment in Southern Africa: Who will do the job? The Lancet. 2004;364(9428):103-107.
  42. Palmer D. Tackling Malawi's Human Resources Crisis. Reproductive Health Matters. 2006;14(27):27-39. doi:10.1016/s0968-8080(06)27244-6
  43. Moullan Y. Can Foreign Health Assistance Reduce the Medical Brain Drain? 2009. https://sites.uclouvain.be/econ/DP/CIACO/CIACO-2009039.pdf.
  44. Schulze Schwering M, Spitzer MS, Kalua K, Batumba HN. Training ophthalmologists for developing economies: an African-German partnership. Postgrad Med J. 2014;90(1060):61-62. doi:10.1136/postgradmedj-2013-132059
  45. Ossai EN, Ibiok NC, Chukwuogo O, Umeobieri AK, Aniwada EC, Ugwunna NC. Rural retention of human resources for heath. Niger J Med. 2012;21(2):138-145.
  46. Sherr K, Mussa A, Chilundo B, et al. Brain drain and health workforce distortions in Mozambique. PLoS One. 2012;7(4):e35840. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0035840
  47. Barnighausen T, Bloom DE. "Conditional scholarships" for HIV/AIDS health workers: Educating and retaining the workforce to provide antiretroviral treatment in sub-Saharan Africa. Social Science & Medicine. 2009;68(3):544-551. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2008.11.009
  48. Cailhol J, Craveiro I, Madede T, et al. Analysis of human resources for health strategies and policies in 5 countries in Sub-Saharan Africa, in response to GFATM and PEPFAR-funded HIV-activities. Globalization and health. 2013;9:52. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-9-52
  49. Shaffer FA, Bakhshi M, Dutka JT, Phillips J. Code for ethical international recruitment practices: the CGFNS alliance case study. Human Resources for Health [Electronic Resource]. 2016;14(Suppl 1):30.
  50. Mandeville KL, Ulaya G, Lagarde M, et al. Early career retention of Malawian medical graduates: a retrospective cohort study. Tropical Medicine & International Health. 2015;20(1):106-114. doi:10.1111/tmi.12408
  51. Mandeville KL, Ulaya G, Lagarde M, Muula AS, Dzowela T, Hanson K. The use of specialty training to retain doctors in Malawi: A discrete choice experiment. Social Science & Medicine. 2016;169:109-118. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.09.034
  52. Brush BL, Sochalski J. International nurse migration: lessons from the Philippines. Policy, Politics, & Nursing Practice. 2007;8(1):37-46.
  53. Yan J. Health services delivery: reframing policies for global nursing migration in North America--a Caribbean perspective. Policy, Politics, & Nursing Practice. 2006;7(3 Suppl).
  54. Geber H. Can mentoring decrease the brain drain of academics from Africa? 3rd World Conference on Learning, Teaching and Educational Leadership. . Social and Behavioral Sciences 93: 215–220. 2013;93:215-220.
  55. Zijlstra EE, Broadhead RL. The College of Medicine in the Republic of Malawi: towards sustainable staff development. Human Resources for Health. 2007;5(1):10. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-5-10
  56. Dambisya Y. A review of non-financial incentives for health worker retention in east and southern Africa2007:54.
  57. Henderson LN, Tulloch J. Incentives for retaining and motivating health workers in Pacific and Asian countries. Human Resources for Health. 2008;6:18-18. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-6-18
  58. Kober K, Van Damme W. Public sector nurses in Swaziland: Can the downturn be reversed? Human Resources for Health. 2006;4 (no pagination)(13). doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1478-4491-4-13
  59. Tambulasi RIC, Chasukwa M. Holding the brains back in: An assessment of measures against brain drain in the Malawian health sector. Africa Review. 2015;7(2):104-120. doi:10.1080/09744053.2015.1030867
  60. Tambulasi RIC. Labour Crisis and Innovation in Developing Countries: An Analysis of Locum Program for Health Personnel in Malawi. International Journal of Public Administration. 2012;35(8):524-531. doi:10.1080/01900692.2012.661188
  61. Reid S. Compulsory community service for doctors in South Africa-an evaluation of the first year. South African Medical Journal. 2001;91(4):329-335.
  62. Salmon ME, Yan J, Hewitt H, Guisinger V. Managed migration: the Caribbean approach to addressing nursing services capacity. Health Serv Res. 2007;42(3 Pt 2):1354-1372. doi:10.1111/j.1475-6773.2007.00708.x
  63. Chimbari M, Madhina D, Nyamangara F, Mtandwa H, Damba V. Retention incentives for health workers in Zimbabwe. EQUINET Discussion Paper Series 65. 2008. https://equinetafrica.org/sites/default/files/uploads/documents/Diss65ZimHRH.pdf. Accessed 1 August 2019.
  64. Mufunda J, Chatora R, Ndambakuwa Y, Samkange C, Sigola L, Vengesa P. Challenges in training the ideal Doctor for Africa: lessons learned from Zimbabwe. Medical Teacher. 2007;29(9):878-881.
  65. Iipinge S, Dambisya YM, Loewenson R, et al. Incentives for health worker retention in east and southern Africa: Learning from country research. 2009. http://harep.org/Agriculture/Diss78synthesisHRH09.pdf.
  66. Masango S, Gathu K, Sibandze S. Retention strategies for Swaziland’s health sector workforce: assessing the impact of non-financial incentives. Harare2008: https://equinetafrica.org/sites/default/files/uploads/documents/Diss68_swaziHRH.pdf.
  67. van Rensburg HCJ. South Africa's protracted struggle for equal distribution and equitable access - still not there. Human Resources for Health. 2014;12. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-12-26
  68. Darko VM, Nyanteh F, Boni P. Migration trends of Ghanaian nurses and midwives: impact of a recent policy implementation. West African Journal of Nursing. 2006;17(2):178-182.
  69. George A, Blaauw D, Thompson J, Green-Thompson L. Doctor retention and distribution in post-apartheid South Africa: tracking medical graduates (2007-2011) from one university. Human Resources for Health. 2019;17(1):1-9. doi:10.1186/s12960-019-0439-4
  70. Paina L, Ungureanu M, Olsavszky V. Implementing the Code of Practice on International Recruitment in Romania - exploring the current state of implementation and what Romania is doing to retain its domestic health workforce. Human Resources for Health [Electronic Resource]. 2016;14(Suppl 1):30.
  71. Hammett D. Physician migration in the global south between Cuba and South Africa. International Migration. 2014;52(4):41-52. doi:10.1111/imig.12127
  72. Kanchanachitra C, Lindelow M, Johnston T, et al. Human resources for health in southeast Asia: shortages, distributional challenges, and international trade in health services. Lancet. 2011;377(9767):769-781. doi:https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(10)62035-1
  73. Walton-Roberts M, Runnels V, Rajan SI, et al. Causes, consequences, and policy responses to the migration of health workers: key findings from India. Human Resources for Health. 2017;15:1-18. doi:10.1186/s12960-017-0199-y
  74. George G, Quinlan T, Reardon C, Aguilera J-Fo. Where are we short and who are we short of? A review of the human resources for health in South Africa. Health SA Gesondheid. 2012;17(1):1-7. doi:10.4102/hsag.v17i1.622
  75. Chirwa Y, Mashange W, Chandiwana P, et al. Understanding health worker incentives in post-crisis settings: policies to attract and retain health workers in rural areas in Zimbabwe since 1997, a document review 2014. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/57a089fbe5274a27b2000365/UnderstandinghealthworkerincentivesdocreviewZimFinal210115.pdf. Accessed 1 August, 2019.
  76. Mullan F, Frehywot S, Omaswa F, et al. Medical schools in sub-Saharan Africa. The Lancet. 2011;377(9771):1113-1121. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(10)61961-7
  77. van de Pas R, Mans L, de Ponte G, Dambisya Y. The Code of Practice and its enduring relevance in Europe and Eastern and Southern Africa. Human Resources for Health [Electronic Resource]. 2016;14(Suppl 1):30.
  78. Manning C, Sidorenko A. The Regulation of Professional Migration: Insights from the Health and IT Sectors in ASEAN. The World Economy. 2007;30(7):1084-1113. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9701.2007.01013.x
  79. Efendi F, Chen C-M. Monitoring the implementation of the WHO Global Code of Practice on the international recruitment of health personnel: the case of Indonesia. BMC Health Services Research. 2014;14(2):P35. doi:10.1186/1472-6963-14-S2-P35
  80. Lassey AT, Lassey PD, Boamah M. Career destinations of University of Ghana Medical School graduates of various year groups. Ghana Medical Journal. 2013;47(2):87-91.
  81. Wiwanitkit V. Mandatory rural service for health care workers in Thailand. Rural and Remote Health. 2011;11(1).
  82. Enlinson M, Débora M. Assessing the impact of More Doctors Program on health care indicators. . 2018 494.
  83. Harris M. Mais Medicos (More Doctors) Program - a view from England. Ciência & Saúde Coletiva 2016;21(9):2919-2923.
  84. Bode CO, Olatosi J, Amposah G, Desalu I. Has the middle-level anaesthesia manpower training program of the West African College of Surgeons fulfilled its objectives? Anaesthesia & Intensive Care. 2013;41(3):359-362.
  85. Derbew M, Laytin AD, Dicker RA. The surgical workforce shortage and successes in retaining surgical trainees in Ethiopia: a professional survey. Human Resources for Health. 2016;14. doi:10.1186/s12960-016-0126-7
  86. Labonte R, Sanders D, Mathole T, et al. Health worker migration from South Africa: causes, consequences and policy responses. Hum Resour Health. 2015;13:92. doi:10.1186/s12960-015-0093-4
  87. Hongoro C, McPake B. How to bridge the gap in human resources for health. The Lancet. 2004;364(9443):1451-1456. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(04)17229-2
  88. Willis-Shattuck M, Bidwell P, Thomas S, Wyness L, Blaauw D, Ditlopo P. Motivation and retention of health workers in developing countries: a systematic review. BMC Health Services Research. 2008;8(247):04.
  89. Ndetei DM, Khasakhala L, Omolo JO. Incentives for health worker retention in Kenya: An assessment of current practice. Harare, Regional Network for Equity in Health in Southern Africa (EQUINET), 2008 (Discussion Paper Series No. 62). 2008.
  90. Oman KM, Usher K, Moulds R. Lack of coordination between health policy and medical education: A contributing factor to the resignation of specialist trainees in Fiji? New Zealand Medical Journal. 2009;122(1291):28-38.
  91. Forman L. Justice and justiciability: Advancing solidarity and justice through south africans' right to health jurisprudence. . Medicine and Law. 2008;27(3):661-684.
  92. Nwena C. Access to health care services as a justiciable socio-economic right under the South African constitution. . Medical Law International. 2003;6:13-23.
  93. Perehudoff SK, Alexandrov NV, Hogerzeil HV. Legislating for universal access to medicines: a rights-based cross-national comparison of UHC laws in 16 countries. Health Policy Plan. 2019;34(Supplement_3):iii48-iii57. doi:10.1093/heapol/czy101
  94. Hibbert N. Human Rights and Social Justice. Laws. 2017;6(2). doi:10.3390/laws6020007
  95. Onazi O. Are human rights enough? Human Rights from Community: Edinburgh University Press; 2013:50-68.
  96. Onazi O. Before Rights and Responsibilities: An African Ethos of Citizenship. African Legal Theory and Contemporary Problems2014:153-172.
  97. Onazi O. Human rights and community unlocking the deadlock. Human Rights from Community. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 2013:23-49.
  98. Gavrilets S, Richerson PJ. Collective action and the evolution of social norm internalization. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017;114(23):6068-6073. doi:10.1073/pnas.1703857114
  99. Jagers SC, Harring N, Lofgren A, et al. On the preconditions for large-scale collective action. Ambio. 2020;49(7):1282-1296. doi:10.1007/s13280-019-01284-w
  100. Stangl AL, Singh D, Windle M, et al. A systematic review of selected human rights programs to improve HIV-related outcomes from 2003 to 2015: what do we know? BMC Infectious Diseases. 2019;19(1):209. doi:10.1186/s12879-019-3692-1
  101. Hasselgård-Rowe J, Mpinga EK. Justiciability of the Right to Health in South Africa and Switzerland through the Lens of its Normative Components. International Human Rights Law Review. 2014;3(1):1-28. doi:10.1163/22131035-00301007
  102. United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commisioner. Human rights and indicators: Rationale and some concerns . . Human rights indicators: A guide to measurement and implementation. New York and Geneva: United Nations 2011:10-24.
  103. Pawson R. Evidence-based Policy2006. doi:10.4135/9781849209120
  104. Dieleman M, Kane S, Zwanikken P, Gerretsen B. Realist review and synthesis of retention studies for health workrers in rural and remote areas Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization and Royal Tropical Institute, Netherlands 2011. 1.
  105. Abbiate T. Ebenezer Durojaye (ed.), Litigating the Right to Health in Africa: Challenges and Prospects. African Journal of International and Comparative Law. 2016;24(4):615-617. doi:10.3366/ajicl.2016.0176
  106. Bourgeault IL, Maier CB, Dieleman M, et al. The COVID-19 pandemic presents an opportunity to develop more sustainable health workforces. Hum Resour Health. 2020;18(1):83. doi:10.1186/s12960-020-00529-0
  107. UN General Assembly. Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 1948. https://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b3712c.html. Accessed 6 January, 2022.

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 12 January 2022
  • Receive Date: 25 March 2021
  • Revise Date: 11 January 2022
  • Accept Date: 11 January 2022