Rhetoric, Reality and Racism: The Governance of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Workers in a State Government Health Service in Australia

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 College of Public Health Medical and Veterinary Sciences, James Cook University, Townsville, QLD, Australia

2 Torres and Cape Hospital and Health Services (TCHSS), Cairns, QLD, Australia

3 Centre for Primary Health Care & Equity, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia

4 School of Population Health, UNSW, Sydney, NSW, Australia

5 School of Social Sciences, UNSW, Sydney, NSW, Australia

6 School of Public Health and Social Work, Queensland University of Technology (QUT), Brisbane, QLD, Australia

7 NT Health, Darwin, NT, Australia

8 Menzies School of Health Research, Darwin, NT, Australia

Abstract

Background 
In northern Australia, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Workers (A&TSIHWs) are unique members of nominally integrated teams of primary care professionals. Spurred by research documenting ongoing structural violence experienced by Indigenous health providers and more recent challenges to recruitment and retention of A&TSIHWs, this study aimed to explore whether the governance of the A&TSIHW role supports full and meaningful participation.

Methods 
The qualitative study was co-designed by a team of Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander and non-Indigenous collaborators. Data collection comprised document review and interviews with A&TSIHWs (n = 51), clinicians (n = 19) community members (n = 8) and administrators (n = 5) in a north Queensland health district. We analysed governance at multiple levels (regulatory, organisational, and socio-cultural) and used critical race theory to deepen exploration of the role of race and racism in shaping it.

Results 
Governance of the A&TSIHW role occurs within a health system where racism is built into, and amplified by, formal and informal rules at all levels. Racially discriminatory structures such as the previous but long-standing relegation of A&TSIHW into the same career stream as cleaners were mirrored in discriminatory rules and managerial practices such as an absence of career-specific corporate support and limited opportunities to participate in, or represent to, key leadership groups. These interacted with and helped perpetuate workplace norms permissive of disrespect and abuse by non-Indigenous professionals. Ongoing resistance to the structural violence required of, and demonstrated by A&TSIHWs speaks to the gap between rhetoric and reality of governance for A&TSIHWs.

Conclusion 
Strengthening governance to support A&TSIHWs requires critical attention be given to the role of race and racism in regulatory structures, organisational practice, and inter-professional relationships. Addressing all domains will be essential to achieve systemic change that recognises, supports and embeds the unique knowledge, skills and functions of the A&TSIHW role.

Keywords


  1. Schaaf M, Warthin C, Freedman L, Topp SM. The community health worker as service extender, cultural broker and social change agent: a critical interpretive synthesis of roles, intent and accountability. BMJ Glob Health. 2020;5(6):e002296. doi:1136/bmjgh-2020-002296
  2. Schneider H. The governance of national community health worker programmes in low- and middle-income countries: an empirically based framework of governance principles, purposes and tasks. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2019;8(1):18-27. doi:15171/ijhpm.2018.92
  3. Kok MC, Ormel H, Broerse JEW, et al. Optimising the benefits of community health workers' unique position between communities and the health sector: a comparative analysis of factors shaping relationships in four countries. Glob Public Health. 2017;12(11):1404-1432. doi:1080/17441692.2016.1174722
  4. Topp SM, Edelman A, Taylor S. "We are everything to everyone": a systematic review of factors influencing the accountability relationships of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers (AHWs) in the Australian health system. Int J Equity Health. 2018;17(1):67. doi:1186/s12939-018-0779-z
  5. Tregenza J, Abbott K. Rhetoric and Reality: Aboriginal Health Worker Roles in Central Australia. Alice Springs: Central Australian Aboriginal Congress; 1995.
  6. McDermott RA, Schmidt B, Preece C, et al. Community health workers improve diabetes care in remote Australian Indigenous communities: results of a pragmatic cluster randomized controlled trial. BMC Health Serv Res. 2015;15:68. doi:1186/s12913-015-0695-5
  7. Topp SM, Tully J, Cummins R, et al. Unique knowledge, unique skills, unique role: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers in Queensland, Australia. BMJ Glob Health. 2021;6(7):e006028. doi:1136/bmjgh-2021-006028
  8. Davidson PM, Digiacomo M, Abbott P, et al. A partnership model in the development and implementation of a collaborative, cardiovascular education program for Aboriginal Health Workers. Aust Health Rev. 2008;32(1):139-146. doi:1071/ah080139
  9. Abbott K, Beck T, Cutter T, Nelson H, Armstrong M. Aboriginal community health workers: our screening program. Aborig Isl Health Work J. 1979;3(3):24-28.
  10. Jones J, Buzzacott T, Briscoe G, Murray R, Murray R. Beyond Sandy Blight. Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; 2008.
  11. Weston A. Development of an online yarning place for Indigenous health workers. Aborig Isl Health Work J. 2011;35(5):5-6.
  12. Wilson RD, Wilkie M. Bringing Them Home: Report of the National Inquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children from Their Families. Canberra: Australian Human Rights Commission; 1997.
  13. Wilson TJ, Link-Up NSW. In the Best Interest of the Child? Stolen Children: Aboriginal Pain, White Shame. Canberra, Australia: Aboriginal History Incorporated; 1997.
  14. Waterworth P, Pescud M, Braham R, Dimmock J, Rosenberg M. Factors influencing the health behaviour of Indigenous Australians: perspectives from support people. PLoS One. 2015;10(11):e0142323. doi:1371/journal.pone.0142323
  15. Yashadhana A, Fields T, Blitner G, Stanley R, Zwi AB. Trust, culture and communication: determinants of eye health and care among Indigenous people with diabetes in Australia. BMJ Glob Health. 2020;5(1):e001999. doi:1136/bmjgh-2019-001999
  16. The Lancet. Closing the gap for Aboriginal health. Lancet. 2019;393(10173):718. doi:1016/s0140-6736(19)30405-2
  17. Queensland Productivity Commission. FINAL REPORT Service Delivery in Remote and Discrete Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Communities: Final Report. Brisbane: Queensland Productivity Commission; 2017. https://qpc.blob.core.windows.net/wordpress/2018/06/Summary-Report-Service-Delivery-Final-Report.pdf;2017.
  18. Ward R, Gorman D. Racism, discrimination and health services to aboriginal people in South West Queensland. Aborig Isl Health Work J. 2010;34(6):3-5.
  19. Hall S. Race: The Floating Signifier. Northampton, MA: Media Education Foundation; 1996.
  20. Fanon F. Black Skin, White Masks. New York, NY: Grove Press; 1967.
  21. Garner S. Chapter 1: the idea of ‘race’ and the practice of racisms. In: Garner S, ed. Racisms: An Introduction. 2nd Ed. UK: SAGE Publications; 2017.
  22. Leonardo Z. The souls of white folk: critical pedagogy, whiteness studies, and globalization discourse. Race Ethn Educ. 2002;5(1):29-50. doi:1080/13613320120117180
  23. Moreton-Robinson A. Witnessing the workings of white possession in the workplace: leesa’s testimony. Aust Fem Law J. 2007;26(1):81-93. doi:1080/13200968.2007.10854379
  24. Bond C. Talkin’ down to the Black woman. Aust Fem Law J. 2019;45(2):185-189. doi:1080/13200968.2020.1837536
  25. Bond C, Brough M, Willis J, et al. Beyond the pipeline: a critique of the discourse surrounding the development of an Indigenous primary healthcare workforce in Australia. Aust J Prim Health. 2019;25(5):389-394. doi:1071/py19044
  26. Howard D. Supporting your Aboriginal colleagues. Aborig Isl Health Work J. 2011;35(5):7.
  27. Trueman SW, Mills J, Usher K. Racism in contemporary Australian nursing. Aborig Isl Health Work J. 2011;35(5):19-22.
  28. Biggs A, Cook L. Health in Australia: A Quick Guide. Canberra: Department of Parliamentary Services; 2018.
  29. Department of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Partnerships (DATSIP). Moving Ahead: A Strategic Approach to Increasing the Participation of Aboriginal People and Torres Strait Islander People in Queensland’s Economy 2016-2022. Brisbane: Queensland Government; 2016. https://www.datsip.qld.gov.au/resources/datsima/publications/corporate/moving-ahead-strategy.pdf.
  30. Queensland Health. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Workforce Strategic Framework 2016-2026. Brisbane: Queensland Government; 2016. https://www.health.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0023/628340/aboriginal-torres-strait-islander-workforce-framework.pdf.
  31. Queensland Health. Queensland Health Workforce Diversity and Inclusion Strategy 2017-22. Brisbane: Queensland Government; 2017. https://www.health.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0033/667167/qh-diversity-and-inclusion-strategy.pdf.
  32. Wright A, Briscoe K, Lovett R. A national profile of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers, 2006-2016. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2019;43(1):24-26. doi:1111/1753-6405.12864
  33. National Industry Insights. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Workers. https://nationalindustryinsights.aisc.net.au/industries/health/aboriginal-and-torres-strait-islander-health-workers. 2020. Accessed May 26, 2020. Published
  34. Workforce Strategy Branch, Queensland Health. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Worker Career Structure Review - Final Report July 2019. Brisbane: Queensland Government; 2019. https://www.together.org.au/files/2415/6887/4935/ATSIHWCS-Review-Final-Report-July-2019-1.pdf.
  35. Bhaskar R. The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of the Contemporary Human Sciences. New York: Routledge; 2014.
  36. Abimbola S, Negin J, Jan S, Martiniuk A. Towards people-centred health systems: a multi-level framework for analysing primary health care governance in low- and middle-income countries. Health Policy Plan. 2014;29 Suppl 2:ii29-39. doi:1093/heapol/czu069
  37. Queensland Government. Torres and Cape Hospital and Health Service. https://www.health.qld.gov.au/torres-cape. Accessed August 27, 2021.
  38. Personal Communication. Manager Health Worker Services, Torres and Cape Hospital and Health Service. Cairns, Queensland; 2019.
  39. Helbig K, Miles J. Queensland Health to Axe More Than 2700 Jobs as Part of Campbell Newman Cost-Cutting. The West Australian; 2012.
  40. Schmidt B, Mills P. Review of Torres Model of Care: Torres and NPA District Health Service, 2012. Cairns, Australia; 2012.
  41. Rigney LI. Internationalization of an Indigenous anticolonial cultural critique of research methodologies: a guide to Indigenist research methodology and its principles. Wicazo Sa Rev. 1999;14(2):109-121. doi:2307/1409555
  42. Martin K, Mirraboopa B. Ways of knowing, being and doing: a theoretical framework and methods for Indigenous and Indigenist research. J Aust Stud. 2003;27(76):203-214. doi:1080/14443050309387838
  43. Askew DA, Togni SJ, Schluter PJ, et al. Investigating the feasibility, acceptability and appropriateness of outreach case management in an urban Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander primary health care service: a mixed methods exploratory study. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016;16:178. doi:1186/s12913-016-1428-0
  44. Bainbridge R, McCalman J, Tsey K. Improving Indigenous Australian governance: the how and what of capacity strengthening. In: 11th International Conference of the International Society for Third-Sector Research. Vol International Society for Third-Sector Research Working Paper Series (IX). Muenster, Germany: International Society for Third-Sector Research (ISTR); 2014.
  45. Holland J, Ruedin L, Scott-Villiers P, Sheppard H. Tackling the governance of socially inclusive service delivery. Public Manag Rev. 2012;14(2):181-196. doi:1080/14719037.2012.657919
  46. Adams K, Spratling M. Future Directions for Aboriginal Health Worker Training in Victoria: A Report to VACCHO Members About Issues and Considerations Relating to the Development of Aboriginal Health Worker Training. Melbourne: Victorian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (VACCHO); 1999.
  47. Hill PS, Shannon C. Empowering Indigenous health workers through management training. Physician Exec. 1993;19(2):22-26.
  48. Sibthorpe B, Becking FB, Humes G. Positions and training of the Indigenous health workforce. Aust N Z J Public Health. 1998;22(6):648-652. doi:1111/j.1467-842x.1998.tb01463.x
  49. Tuxworth I. The establishment, progress and success of the Northern Territory's Aboriginal Health Worker training scheme. Aust Health Rev. 1982;5(5):29-30.
  50. The State of Queensland (Queensland Health). Course information – Certificate IV in Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander Primary Health Care Practice. https://www.health.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/731252/factsheet-1-course-information.pdf.
  51. The State of Queensland (Queensland Health). Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Practitioner: Scope of Practice Guideline. 2018. https://www.health.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/731251/ATSIHP-scope-practice-guideline.pdf.
  52. The State of Queensland (Queensland Health). About the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Practitioner. https://www.health.qld.gov.au/clinical-practice/guidelines-procedures/clinical-staff/aboriginal-torres-strait-islander-health-practitioner/about-the-role. Accessed June 11, 2020. Published 2019.
  53. Sian K, Law I, Sayyid S. Racism, Governance, and Public Policy: Beyond Human Rights. New York: Routledge; 2013.
  54. Topp SM, Tully J, Cummins R, et al. Building patient trust in health systems: A qualitative study of facework in the context of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Worker role in Queensland, Australia. Soc Sci Med. 2022;302:114984. doi:1016/j.socscimed.2022.114984
  55. Bourke CJ, Marrie H, Marrie A. Transforming institutional racism at an Australian hospital. Aust Health Rev. 2019;43(6):611-618. doi:1071/ah18062
  56. Clark D. Environmental health officers' understanding about an aboriginal environmental health worker program in the Northern Territory. Aust N Z J Public Health. 1999;23(1):93-94. doi:1111/j.1467-842x.1999.tb01212.x
  57. Clark T, Dodson S, Guivarra N, Widders Hunt Y. “We’re not treated equally as Indigenous people or as women”: the perspectives and experiences of Indigenous women in Australian public relations. Public Relat Inq. 2021;10(2):163-183. doi:1177/2046147x211005358
  58. Jennings W, Bond C, Hill PS. The power of talk and power in talk: a systematic review of Indigenous narratives of culturally safe healthcare communication. Aust J Prim Health. 2018;24(2):109-115. doi:1071/py17082
  59. Williams DR. Racism and health. In: Whitefield KE, ed. Closing the Gap: Improving the Health of Minority Elders in the New Millennium. Washington, DC: Gerontological Society of America; 2004:69-80.
  60. Priest N, Williams DR. Structural racism: a call to action for health and health disparities research. Ethn Dis. 2021;31(Suppl 1):285-288. doi:18865/ed.31.S1.285
  61. Yashadhana A, Lee L, Massie J, Burnett A. Non-clinical eye care support for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians: a systematic review. Med J Aust. 2020;212(5):222-228. doi:5694/mja2.50480
  62. Kerrigan V, McGrath SY, Majoni SW, et al. From "stuck" to satisfied: Aboriginal people's experience of culturally safe care with interpreters in a Northern Territory hospital. BMC Health Serv Res. 2021;21(1):548. doi:1186/s12913-021-06564-4
  63. Zhao Y, Russell DJ, Guthridge S, et al. Cost impact of high staff turnover on primary care in remote Australia. Aust Health Rev. 2019;43(6):689-695. doi:1071/ah17262
  64. Wakerman J, Humphreys J, Russell D, et al. Remote health workforce turnover and retention: what are the policy and practice priorities? Hum Resour Health. 2019;17(1):99. doi:1186/s12960-019-0432-y
  65. National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Worker Association (NATSIHWA). Cultural Safety Framework: National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Workers Association. https://www.naatsihwp.org.au/sites/default/files/natsihwa-cultural_safety-framework_summary.pdf.
  66. Indigenous Allied Health Association. IAHA Cultural Responsiveness Framework 2019. https://iaha.com.au/workforce-support/training-and-development/cultural-responsiveness-in-action-training/.
  67. Queensland Government, Queensland Aboriginal and Islander Health Council (QAIHC). Making Tracks Together: Queensland’s Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Equity Framework. Brisbane: Queensland Government, QAIHC; 2021.
  68. Queensland Government. Hospital and Health Boards (Health Equity Strategies) Amendment Regulation 2021. Brisbane: Queensland Government; 2021. https://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/view/pdf/asmade/sl-2021-0034.
  69. Gwynne K, Lincoln M. Developing the rural health workforce to improve Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health outcomes: a systematic review. Aust Health Rev. 2017;41(2):234-238. doi:1071/ah15241
  70. Yashadhana A, Fields T, Burnett A, Zwi AB. Re-examining the gap: a critical realist analysis of eye health inequity among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians. Soc Sci Med. 2021;284:114230. doi:1016/j.socscimed.2021.114230
  71. Taylor K, Guerin PT. Health Care and Indigenous Australians: Cultural Safety in Practice. 2nd ed. South Yarra, Victoria: Palgrave Macmillan; 2014.
  72. Shepherd SM. Cultural awareness workshops: limitations and practical consequences. BMC Med Educ. 2019;19(1):14. doi:1186/s12909-018-1450-5
  73. Jongen C, McCalman J, Bainbridge R, Clifford A. Cultural Competence in Health: A Review of the Evidence. Singapore: Springer; 2018.
  74. Angus J. Strategies to support the recruitment, retention and professional development of Indigenous managers. Aborig Isl Health Work J. 1999;23(6):28-33.
  75. Wakerman J, Matthews S, Hill P, Gibson O. Beyond Charcoal Lane: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Managers: Issues and Strategies to Assist Recruitment, Retention and Professional Development. Alice Springs, NT: Centre for Remote Health; 2000.
  76. Mackean T, Withall E, Dwyer J, Wilson A. Role of Aboriginal Health Workers and Liaison Officers in quality care in the Australian acute care setting: a systematic review. Aust Health Rev. 2020;44(3):427-433. doi:1071/ah19101
  77. Mithen V, Kerrigan V, Dhurrkay G, et al. Aboriginal patient and interpreter perspectives on the delivery of culturally safe hospital-based care. Health Promot J Austr. 2021;32 Suppl 1:155-165. doi:1002/hpja.415

Articles in Press, Corrected Proof
Available Online from 24 April 2022
  • Receive Date: 01 September 2021
  • Revise Date: 24 February 2022
  • Accept Date: 22 April 2022
  • First Publish Date: 24 April 2022