Doctor Retention: A Cross-sectional Study of How Ireland Has Been Losing the Battle

Document Type: Original Article

Authors

1 RCSI Division of Population Health Sciences, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, Ireland

2 School of Psychology, Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland

3 National Doctors Training and Planning, Health Service Executive, Dublin 8, Ireland

4 Department of Mathematics & Statistics, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland

Abstract

Background
The failure of some high-income countries to retain their medical graduates is one driver of doctor immigration from low- and middle-income countries. Ireland, which attracts many international medical graduates, implemented a doctor retention strategy from early 2015. This study measures junior doctors’ migration intentions, the reasons they leave and likelihood of them returning. The aim is to identify the characteristics and patterns of doctors who plan to emigrate to inform targeted measures to retain these doctors.

 
Methods
A national sample of 1148 junior hospital doctors completed an online survey in early 2018, eliciting their experiences of training and working conditions. Respondents were asked to choose between the following career options: remain in Ireland, go and return, go and stay away, or quit medicine. Bivariate analyses and a two-stage multivariable analysis were used to model the factors associated with these outcomes.

 
Results
45% of respondents planned to remain in Ireland, 35% leave but return later, 17% leave and not return; and 3% to quit medicine. An intention to go abroad versus remain in Ireland was independently associated (P < .05) with the doctor being under 30 years (odds ratio [OR] = 1.09 per year under 30), a non-European Union (EU) national (OR = 1.54), a trainee (OR = 1.50), and with hospital specialization, especially in Anesthesiology (OR = 5.09). Respondents were more likely to remain if they had experienced improvements in supervision and training costs. Intention to go abroad and not return versus go and return was independently associated (P < .05) with: age over 30 years (OR = 1.16 per year over 30); being a non-EU (OR = 9.85) or non-Irish EU (OR = 3.42) national; having trained through a graduate entry pathway (OR = 2.17), specializing in Psychiatry (OR = 4.76) and reporting that mentoring had become worse (OR = 5.85).
 

Conclusion
Ireland’s doctor retention strategy has not addressed the root causes of poor training and working experiences in Irish hospitals. It needs a more diversified retention strategy that addresses under-staffing, facilitates circular migration by younger trainees who choose to train abroad, identifies and addresses specialty-specific factors, and builds mentoring linkages between trainees and senior specialists.

Highlights

Supplementary File 1 (Download)

 

Commentary Published on this Paper

  • Doctor Retention in Ireland - What it may mean for the Global Health Workforce Reform Agenda; Comment on “Doctor Retention: A Cross-sectional Study of How Ireland Has Been Losing the Battle”

         Abstract | PDF

Keywords


  1. World Health Organisation (WHO). WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel. Geneva: WHO; 2010.
  2. Ramos P, Alves H. Migration intentions among Portuguese junior doctors: results from a survey. Health Policy. 2017;121(12):1208-1214. doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2017.09.016
  3. Lambert TW, Smith F, Goldacre MJ. Why doctors consider leaving UK medicine: qualitative analysis of comments from questionnaire surveys three years after graduation. J R Soc Med. 2018;111(1):18-30. doi:10.1177/0141076817738502
  4. Pantenburg B, Kitze K, Luppa M, König HH, Riedel-Heller SG. Physician emigration from Germany: insights from a survey in Saxony, Germany. BMC Health Serv Res. 2018;18(1):341. doi:10.1186/s12913-018-3142-6
  5. Suciu ŞM, Popescu CA, Ciumageanu MD, Buzoianu AD. Physician migration at its roots: a study on the emigration preferences and plans among medical students in Romania. Hum Resour Health. 2017;15(1):6. doi:10.1186/s12960-017-0181-8
  6. Glinos IA. Health professional mobility in the European Union: exploring the equity and efficiency of free movement. Health Policy. 2015;119(12):1529-1536. doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2015.08.010
  7. Filippidis FT. Emigrating young physicians leave Greece with an aging health workforce. J Public Health (Oxf). 2016;38(4):e587. doi:10.1093/pubmed/fdv193
  8. Moris D, Karachaliou GS, Kontos M. Residency training in Greece: job dissatisfaction paves the way to brain drain. Ann Transl Med. 2017;5(5):123. doi:10.21037/atm.2017.03.03
  9. Scharer S, Freitag A. Physicians' exodus: why medical graduates leave Austria or do not work in clinical practice. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2015;127(9-10):323-329. doi:10.1007/s00508-015-0786-7
  10. Seitz T, Turk BR, Löffler-Stastka H. Can we still stop the migration of physicians from Austria?: an evaluation of clinical internships by students of the Medical University of Vienna. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2017;129(1-2):65-69. doi:10.1007/s00508-016-1095-5
  11. General Medical Council. The State of Medical Education and Practice in the UK. UK: General Medical Council; 2018.
  12. Shanafelt TD, Boone S, Tan L, et al. Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among US physicians relative to the general US population. Arch Intern Med. 2012;172(18):1377-1385. doi:10.1001/archinternmed.2012.3199
  13. Rich A, Viney R, Needleman S, Griffin A, Woolf K. 'You can't be a person and a doctor': the work-life balance of doctors in training-a qualitative study. BMJ Open. 2016;6(12):e013897. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2016-013897
  14. Department of Health and Children. The report of the national joint steering group on the working hours of non consultant hospital doctors. Dublin: Department of Health and Children; 2001.
  15. Bidwell P, Humphries N, Dicker P, Thomas S, Normand C, Brugha R. The national and international implications of a decade of doctor migration in the Irish context. Health Policy. 2013;110(1):29-38. doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2012.10.002
  16. OECD Health Statistics 2019- Health Workforce Migration. OECD; 2019. https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=HEALTH_WFMI.   
  17. Irish Medical Council. Medical Workforce Intelligence Report: A Report on the 2016 and 2017 Annual Registration Retention & Voluntary Registration Withdrawal Surveys. Dublin: Irish Medical Council; 2019.
  18. Report of the Working Group on Undergraduate Medical Education and Training Report of the Working Group on Undergraduate Medical Education and Training (the Fottrell Report). Dublin: Department of Health and Children; 2006.
  19. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Recent Trends in International Migration of Doctors, Nurses and Medical Students. Paris: OECD; 2019.
  20. Report of the NDTP working group on doctors not in training: optimising the Irish medical workforce. National Doctor Training and Planning, Health Service Executive. September 2019. Dublin: HSE; 2019.
  21. Eighth Annual Assessment of NCHD Posts 2017-2018. HSE; 2017-2018.
  22. Humphries N, McAleese S, Matthews A, Brugha R. 'Emigration is a matter of self-preservation. The working conditions . . . are killing us slowly': qualitative insights into health professional emigration from Ireland. Hum Resour Health. 2015;13:35. doi:10.1186/s12960-015-0022-6
  23. Clarke N, Crowe S, Humphries N, et al. Factors influencing trainee doctor emigration in a high income country: a mixed methods study. Hum Resour Health. 2017;15(1):66. doi:10.1186/s12960-017-0239-7
  24. Walsh A, Brugha R. Brain Drain to Brain Gain: Ireland's Two-Way Flow of Doctors. Dublin: Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland; 2017.
  25. Humphries N, Crowe S, McDermott C, McAleese S, Brugha R. The consequences of Ireland's culture of medical migration. Hum Resour Health. 2017;15(1):87. doi:10.1186/s12960-017-0263-7
  26. Humphries N, Connell J, Negin J, Buchan J. Tracking the leavers: towards a better understanding of doctor migration from Ireland to Australia 2008-2018. Hum Resour Health. 2019;17(1):36. doi:10.1186/s12960-019-0365-5
  27. Gish O. Emigration and the supply and demand for medical manpower: the Irish case. Minerva. 1969;7(4):668-679. doi:10.1007/BF01099540
  28. Humphries N, McDermott AM, Conway E, et al. 'Everything was just getting worse and worse': deteriorating job quality as a driver of doctor emigration from Ireland. Hum Resour Health. 2019;17(1):97. doi:10.1186/s12960-019-0424-y
  29. Zubaran C. Balancing the act: the international migration of medical graduates. Monash Bioeth Rev. 2011;29(3):05.01-12.
  30. Cronin F, Clarke N, Hendrick L, Conroy R, Brugha R. The impacts of training pathways and experiences during intern year on doctor emigration from Ireland. Hum Resour Health. 2019;17(1):74. doi:10.1186/s12960-019-0407-z
  31. Sharma A, Lambert TW, Goldacre MJ. Why UK-trained doctors leave the UK: cross-sectional survey of doctors in New Zealand. J R Soc Med. 2012;105(1):25-34. doi:10.1258/jrsm.2011.110146
  32. McAleese S, Clyne B, Matthews A, Brugha R, Humphries N. Gone for good? an online survey of emigrant health professionals using Facebook as a recruitment tool. Hum Resour Health. 2016;14(suppl 1):34. doi:10.1186/s12960-016-0130-y
  33. Brugha R, Cronin F, Clarke N, RCSI Health Workforce Research Group. Retaining our Doctors: Medical Workforce Evidence, 2013-18. Dublin: Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland; 2018.
  34. Report of the National Task Force on Medical Staffing (Hanly report). Dublin: Department of Health and Children; 2003.
  35. Preparing Ireland's Doctors to Meet the Health Needs of the 21st Century: Report of the Postgraduate Medical Education and Training Group (Buttimer report). Dublin: Department of Health and Children; 2006.
  36. Imrie K. Training 21st Century Clinical Leaders. Dublin: Royal College of Physicians of Ireland; 2014.
  37. Strategic Review of Medical Training and Career Structure: Report on Medical Career Structures and Pathways Following Completion of Specialist Training. Dublin: Department of Health; 2014.
  38. Strategic Review of Medical Training and Career Structure: Progress Report. Dublin: Department of Health; 2015.
  39. Strategic Review of Medical Training and Career Structure- Tenth Progress Report. Dublin: Department of Health; 2019.
  40. Strategic Review of Medical Training and Career Structure- Seventh Progress Report. Dublin: Department of Health; 2018.
  41. Crowe S, Clarke N, Brugha R. 'You do not cross them': hierarchy and emotion in doctors' narratives of power relations in specialist training. Soc Sci Med. 2017;186:70-77. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.05.048
  42. Kavanagh PM, O'hare S. Your Training Counts: Results of the National Trainee Experience Survey. Dublin: Medical Council of Ireland; 2014.
  43. Your Training Counts 2015 Results of the National Trainee Survey. Dublin: Medical Council of Ireland; 2015.
  44. Russell H, Maître B, Watson D, Fahey É. Job Stress and Working Conditions: Ireland in Comparative Perspective - An Analysis of the European Working Conditions Survey. Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI); 2018. doi:10.26504/rs84
  45. Akaike H. A new look at the statistical model identification. IEEE Trans Automat Contr. 1974;19(6):716-723. doi:10.1109/TAC.1974.1100705
  46. Kroezen M, Barriball L, Bremner J, et al. Recruitment and Retention of the Health Workforce in Europe Final Report. European Commission; 2018.
  47. Finance MfHa. Ministers for Health and Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform Announce New Sláintecare Contract for Consultants. Irish Government News Service; 2019.
  48. Report of the Public Service Pay Commission. Recruitment and Retention Module 1. Dublin: Public Service Pay Commission; 2018.
  49. IMO. Irish Medical Organisation. Budget Must Address Doctor Recruitment and Retention Crisis. News and Press Releases. IMO; 2019.
  50. Glinos I, Buchan J. Health professionals crossing the European Union’s internal and external borders: a typology and health professional mobility and migration. In: Buchan J, Wismar M, Glinos I, Bremner J, eds. Health Professional Mobility in a Changing Europe: New Dynamics, Mobile Individuals and Policy Responses. World Health Organization; 2014.
  51. Humphries N, Tyrrell E, McAleese S, et al. A cycle of brain gain, waste and drain - a qualitative study of non-EU migrant doctors in Ireland. Hum Resour Health. 2013;11:63. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-11-63
  52. Brugha R, McAleese S, Dicker P, et al. Passing through - reasons why migrant doctors in Ireland plan to stay, return home or migrate onwards to new destination countries. Hum Resour Health. 2016;14(suppl 1):35. doi:10.1186/s12960-016-0121-z
  53. Blanchard P, Truchot D, Albiges-Sauvin L, et al. Prevalence and causes of burnout amongst oncology residents: a comprehensive nationwide cross-sectional study. Eur J Cancer. 2010;46(15):2708-2715. doi:10.1016/j.ejca.2010.05.014
  54. Health Service Executive (HSE). European Working Time Directive Implementation: Guidance on Progressing EWTD Compliance. 17th ed. HSE; 2014.
  55. World Health Organisation (WHO). Global Strategy on Human Resources for Health: Workforce 2030. WHO; 2016.
  56. Hayes B, Prihodova L, Walsh G, Doyle F, Doherty S. What's up doc? a national cross-sectional study of psychological wellbeing of hospital doctors in Ireland. BMJ Open. 2017;7(10):e018023. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018023
  57. Hayes B, Prihodova L, Walsh G, Doyle F, Doherty S. Doctors don't Do-little: a national cross-sectional study of workplace well-being of hospital doctors in Ireland. BMJ Open. 2019;9(3):e025433. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2018-025433
  58. Working Together for Health: The National Strategic Framework for Health and Social Care Workforce Planning. Dublin: Department of Health; 2017.
  59. Committee on the Future of Healthcare Sláintecare Report. Dublin: Oireachtas Committee on the Future of Healthcare  Houses of the Oireachtas; 2017.
  60. Irish doctors return from Australia - ‘You don’t run away from things like this. The Irish Times; 2020.