The Feedback Loop Between the Demand for Voluntary Private Insurance and the Burden of Healthcare System: An Explanatory System Dynamics Model of Hong Kong

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Center for Data Science, New York University, New York City, NY, USA

2 Roche Hong Kong and Macau, Hong Kong SAR, China

3 University Institute of Lisbon (ISCTE-IUL), Lisbon, Portugal

4 Faculty of Sciences, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal

Abstract

Background 
Many countries with universal healthcare have a parallel private healthcare sector due to the waiting time in the public sector. People purchase individual health insurance to pay for private services. Past studies on the relationship between the public sector’s waiting time and the demand for health insurance have two limitations: not considering the capacity of the private sector, and subsequently, the omission of a feedback loop. These limitations are also present in the health insurance policy discussion in Hong Kong, where the public sector is overstretched. A lack of understanding of market dynamics might lead to unrealistic expectations of public policy. This study highlights these limitations, and tries to answer the research question: whether the historical dynamics between the intersectoral imbalance of burden and the demand for health insurance in Hong Kong could be quantitatively explained.

Methods 
A system dynamics model was created based on a negative feedback loop. The model’s initial input was the percentage of population with health insurance in 2009, and to simulate the percentage continuously until 2019. Results from 2015 to 2019 were compared with actual figures to examine the model’s explanatory power. Multivariable sensitivity analysis was performed.

Results 
With initial fluctuation, the simulated result stabilized and was within the acceptable error range from 2015 to 2019. The mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) was 0.94%. At the end of 2019, the simulated percentage of population with health insurance is 36.6% versus the “real value” of 36.7%. Simulated patient admissions and occupancy rates also approximate the reality. Sensitivity analysis demonstrates the robustness of the model.

Conclusion 
We can quantitatively explain the feedback loop between health system burden and demand for health insurance. With local parameterization, this model should be transferable to other universal health systems for a better understanding of the system dynamics and more informed policy-making.

Keywords


  1. Countries that have passed legislation on Universal Health Coverage (UHC). World Health Organization website. https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/indicators/indicator-details/GHO/countries-that-have-passed-legislation-on-universal-health-coverage-(uhc). Accessed June 10, 2021.
  2. Kong X, Yang Y, Gao J, et al. Overview of the health care system in Hong Kong and its referential significance to mainland China. J Chin Med Assoc. 2015;78(10):569-573. doi:1016/j.jcma.2015.02.006
  3. Hurley J, Johnson M. A Review of Evidence Regarding Parallel Systems of Public and Private Finance. Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis (CHEPA), McMaster University; 2014.
  4. Drug Formulary Management Manual. Hospital Authority website. https://www.ha.org.hk/hadf/Portals/0/Docs/HADF_manual_Eng_2018.pdf. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  5. LCQ10: Using Hong Kong drugs and medical devices in Greater Bay Area. The Government of HKSAR website. https://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/202109/15/P2021091500528.htm. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  6. Johar M, Jones G, Keane M, Savage E, Stavrunova O. Waiting times for elective surgery and the decision to buy private health insurance. Health Econ. 2011;20 Suppl 1:68-86. doi:1002/hec.1707
  7. Private health insurance. Australian Insitute of Health and Welfare website. https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/australias-health/private-health-insurance. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  8. Private Health Insurance Market continued to rise in 2019 but impact of Covid19 is yet to be quantified. The Health Insurance Authority website. https://www.hia.ie/sites/default/files/I%20HIA%20Annual%20Report%202019%20Release%20I%2030%20July%202019%20FINAL.pdf. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  9. Thematic Household Survey Report - Report No. 74. Census and Statistics Department HKSAR website. https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/en/EIndexbySubject.html?pcode=C0000022&scode=453. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  10. Besley T, Hall J, Preston I. The demand for private health insurance: do waiting lists matter? J Public Econ. 1999;72(2):155-181. doi:1016/s0047-2727(98)00108-x
  11. Johar M, Jones G, Keane MP, Savage E, Stavrunova O. The Demand for Private Health Insurance: Do Waiting Lists Matter?–Revisited. Economics Group, Nuffield College, University of Oxford; 2013.
  12. Yanghe Changman Bingren Bushi Zhuansong Gongyuan Ziyuan Yibao Chanpin Jin Gongbu Yi Sheng You Siyuan Lun Gengjiu. [Yanghe often full, patients transferred to public hospitals, VHIS announced today, and doctors worry about longer waiting time in private hospitals]. Specialists Central website. https://specialistscentral.com/en/content/SC-news14/. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  13. LCQ1: Development of private hospitals. The Government of HKSAR website. https://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201111/09/P201111090318.htm. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  14. LCQ12: Private hospitals. The Government of HKSAR website. https://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/200712/12/P200712120126.htm. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  15. Zhao Y, Yihu J. [Hospital Authority is hiring part-time healthcare professionals]. Sing Pao Daily News. November 5, 2018. https://www.singpao.com.hk/index.php?fi=hot&id=86946. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  16. Bíró A, Hellowell M. Public-private sector interactions and the demand for supplementary health insurance in the United Kingdom. Health Policy. 2016;120(7):840-847. doi:1016/j.healthpol.2016.05.002
  17. Voluntary Health Insurance Scheme Consultation Document. Food and Health Bureau website. https://www.vhis.gov.hk/doc/en/information_centre/consultation_full_eng.pdf. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  18. Lee CKM, Tai WC, Ng KKH. System dynamic modelling of patient flow and transferral problem in a mixed public-private healthcare system: a case study of Hong Kong SAR. J Syst Sci Syst Eng. 2020;29(5):590-608. doi:1007/s11518-019-5454-4
  19. Tsui Y, Fong BY. Waiting time in public hospitals: case study of total joint replacement in Hong Kong. Public Adm Policy. 2018;21(2):120-133. doi:1108/pap-10-2018-009
  20. Elective Cataract Surgery. Hospital Authority website. https://www.ha.org.hk/visitor/ha_visitor_index.asp?Content_ID=214184&Lang=ENG&Dimension=1. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  21. Choi M. Patients waiting more than three years for specialist care in Hong Kong, as doctors call for new department to manage public-private sector relationship. South China Morning. May 9, 2019. https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/3009592/patients-waiting-more-three-years-specialist-care. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  22. Siu P. Just one-third of Hong Kong residents satisfied with public hospital services as long waiting times and lack of care top list of gripes. South China Morning Post. May 19, 2019. https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/3010839/just-one-third-hong-kong-residents-satisfied. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  23. Voluntary Health Insurance Scheme Certified Plan Policy Template. Food and Health Bureau website. https://www.vhis.gov.hk/doc/en/information_centre/e_standard_plan_template.pdf. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  24. Voluntary Health Insurance Scheme - Consumer Corner - Tax Reduction. Food and Health Bureau website. https://www.vhis.gov.hk/en/consumer_corner/tax-deduction.html. Updated March 4, 2020. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  25. Gabbay DM, Thagard P, Woods J, Hooker CA. Philosophy of Complex Systems. Vol 10. Elsevier; 2011.
  26. Shmueli G. To explain or to predict? Stat Sci. 2010;25(3):289-310. doi:1214/10-sts330
  27. Lee J. Election Manifesto of Chief Executive Election. 2022. https://www.johnlee2022.hk/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Election-manifesto.pdf. Accessed May 17, 2022.
  28. Liang M. Pangting Lianghui Zhutui Xunzheng Juece Geng Youxiao. [Auditing the “two meetings,” boosting "evidence-based decision-making" more effectively]. IFeng News. March 8, 2019. https://shareapp.cyol.com/cmsfile/News/201903/08/share192181.html?t=1552299139&nid=192181. Accessed May 17 2022.
  29. Nyman JA. The Theory of Demand for Health Insurance. Stanford University Press; 2003.
  30. Cuff K, Hurley J, Mestelman S, Muller A, Nuscheler R. Public and private health-care financing with alternate public rationing rules. Health Econ. 2012;21(2):83-100. doi:1002/hec.1698
  31. Nyman J, Barleen N. The Effect of Supplemental Private Health Insurance on Health Care Purchases, Health, and Welfare in Brazil. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota; 2005.
  32. Suo L, Wanyan R. Why the development of health insurance is regionally imbalanced: evidence from China. Emerg Mark Finance Trade. 2017;53(6):1301-1317. doi:1080/1540496x.2016.1190705
  33. Baugh Littlejohns L, Baum F, Lawless A, Freeman T. The value of a causal loop diagram in exploring the complex interplay of factors that influence health promotion in a multisectoral health system in Australia. Health Res Policy Syst. 2018;16(1):126. doi:1186/s12961-018-0394-x
  34. Marshall DA, Burgos-Liz L, MJ IJ, et al. Selecting a dynamic simulation modeling method for health care delivery research-part 2: report of the ISPOR Dynamic Simulation Modeling Emerging Good Practices Task Force. Value Health. 2015;18(2):147-160. doi:1016/j.jval.2015.01.006
  35. Naseer A, Eldabi T, Young TP. RIGHT: a toolkit for selecting healthcare modelling methods. J Simul. 2010;4(1):2-13. doi:1057/jos.2009.19
  36. Davahli MR, Karwowski W, Taiar R. A system dynamics simulation applied to healthcare: a systematic review. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17(16):5741. doi:3390/ijerph17165741
  37. Jones W, Kotiadis K, O’Hanley JR. Maximising stakeholder learning by looping again through the simulation life-cycle: a case study in public transport. J Oper Res Soc. 2021:1-20. doi:1080/01605682.2021.2007806
  38. Bala BK, Arshad FM, Noh KM. System dynamics. In: Modelling and Simulation. Springer; 2017. p. 274.
  39. Stock and flow. Wikipedia website: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_and_flow. Accessed May 17, 2022.
  40. Homer JB, Hirsch GB. System dynamics modeling for public health: background and opportunities. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(3):452-458. doi:2105/ajph.2005.062059
  41. Statistical Report. Hospital Authority website. https://www3.ha.org.hk/data/HAStatistics/StatisticalReport/. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  42. Tsui EL, Leung GM, Woo PP, Choi S, Lo SV. Under-reporting of inpatient services utilisation in household surveys -- a population-based study in Hong Kong. BMC Health Serv Res. 2005;5(1):31. doi:1186/1472-6963-5-31
  43. Chung RY, Mercer S, Lai FT, Yip BH, Wong MC, Wong SY. Socioeconomic determinants of multimorbidity: a population-based household survey of Hong Kong Chinese. PLoS One. 2015;10(10):e0140040. doi:1371/journal.pone.0140040
  44. Health insurance for individuals in Hong Kong. Legislative Council Secretariat website. https://www.legco.gov.hk/research-publications/english/1718rb03-health-insurance-for-individuals-in-hong-kong-20180703-e.pdf. Updated July 2018. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  45. Siciliani L, Sivey P, Street A. Differences in length of stay for hip replacement between public hospitals, specialised treatment centres and private providers: selection or efficiency? Health Econ. 2013;22(2):234-242. doi:1002/hec.1826
  46. Chen J, Chu X, D R. The Effect of a New Tax Incentive Policy on the Uptake of Voluntary Individual Private Health Insurance: A Systematic Review of Studies with Pre-Post Analysis. Presented at: APRU Global Heath Conference 2021; November 2021, 2021; Hong Kong.
  47. Leung PL, Tsang SW, Yuen PM. An audit on hysterectomy for benign diseases in public hospitals in Hong Kong. Hong Kong Med J. 2007;13(3):187-193.
  48. Reference charges for Common Surgical Procedures Jan - Dec 2020. Gleneagles Hospital website. https://gleneagles.hk/user_uploads/Historical-bill-size-2020-Website.pdf. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  49. Historical Bill Sizes Statistics. Hong Kong Sanatorium & Hospital website. http://hksh-hospital.com/en/fees-charges/historical-bill-sizes-statistics. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  50. King D, Mossialos E. The determinants of private medical insurance prevalence in England, 1997-2000. Health Serv Res. 2005;40(1):195-212. doi:1111/j.1475-6773.2005.00349.x
  51. Vensim Help: Documentation of Delay3 Function. Ventana Systems Inc website. https://www.vensim.com/documentation/fn_delay3.html. Accessed August 14, 2021.
  52. Stephens AS, Broome RA. Impact of emergency department occupancy on waiting times, rates of admission and representation, and length of stay when hospitalised: a data linkage study. Emerg Med Australas. 2019;31(4):555-561. doi:1111/1742-6723.13204
  53. Jofre-Bonet M. Public health care and private insurance demand: the waiting time as a link. Health Care Manag Sci. 2000;3(1):51-71. doi:1023/a:1019024903898
  54. Wong EL, Coulter A, Cheung AW, Yam CH, Yeoh EK, Griffiths SM. Patient experiences with public hospital care: first benchmark survey in Hong Kong. Hong Kong Med J. 2012;18(5):371-380.
  55. McManus ML, Long MC, Cooper A, et al. Variability in surgical caseload and access to intensive care services. Anesthesiology. 2003;98(6):1491-1496. doi:1097/00000542-200306000-00029
  56. 2019 Gross Domestic Product. Census and Statistics Department HKSAR website. https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/en/data/stat_report/product/B1030002/att/B10300022019AN19E0100.pdf. Updated March 2020. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  57. National Accounts. Census and Statistics Department HKSAR website. https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/en/scode250.html#section5. Updated August 13, 2012. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  58. Analysis of Salaries Tax Assessments by Income Group. The Government of HKSAR website. https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-ird-ird_json-ar-sch05. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  59. Thematic Report Household Income Distribution in Hong Kong. Census and Statistics Department HKSAR website. https://www.statistics.gov.hk/pub/B11200572012XXXXB0100.pdf. Updated June 2012. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  60. Tax Rates of Salaries Tax & Personal Assessment. The Government of HKSAR website. https://www.gov.hk/en/residents/taxes/taxfiling/taxrates/salariesrates.htm. Updated May 2021. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  61. Poon CM, Wong ELY, Chau PYK, Yau SY, Yeoh EK. Management decision of hospital surge: assessing seasonal upsurge in inpatient medical bed occupancy rate among public acute hospitals in Hong Kong. QJM. 2019;112(1):11-16. doi:1093/qjmed/hcy217
  62. Key statistics on service demand of A&E Departments and occupancy rates in public hospitals. Hospital Authority website. https://www.ha.org.hk/visitor/ha_visitor_index.asp?Content_ID=235199. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  63. Hong Kong Health Statistics. Department of Health HKSAR website. https://www.dh.gov.hk/tc_chi/statistics/statistics_hs/statistics_hfhk.html. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  64. Appendix B Hong Kong’s Current Healthcare System. 2008. Food and Health Bureau website. https://www.fhb.gov.hk/beStrong/files/consultation/appendixb_eng.pdf. Accessed June 10, 2021.
  65. Statistics Searching. Census and Statistics Department HKSAR website. https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/sc/search.html. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  66. do Rosário Giraldes M. [Private health insurance in Portugal: a comparative analysis of the National Health Surveys, 1995-1996 and 1998-1999]. Cad Saude Publica. 2003;19(1):263-268. doi:1590/s0102-311x2003000100029
  67. Sample Size Calculations for the Modular Grant Application Process Outcome Evaluation Study. https://grants.nih.gov/grants/funding/modular/eval/sample_mgap.doc#:~:text=The%20margin%20of%20error%20in,closely%20related%20to%20sample%20size.&text=For%20all%20samples%20used%20in,a%20given%20margin%20of%20error. Accessed August 15, 2021.
  68. Cebi M, Woodbury SA. Health insurance tax credits, the earned income tax credit, and health insurance coverage of single mothers. Health Econ. 2014;23(5):501-515. doi:1002/hec.2928
  69. Rahmandad H, Sterman JD. Reporting guidelines for simulation-based research in social sciences. Syst Dyn Rev. 2012;28(4):396-411.
  70. System Dynamics Review Author Guidelines. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/page/journal/10991727/homepage/ForAuthors.html. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  71. SDM-DOC. System Dynamics Society website. https://tools.systemdynamics.org/resources-old/sdm-doc/. Accessed April 4, 2022.
  72. Bugert N, Lasch R. Effectiveness of responsive pricing in the face of supply chain disruptions. Comput Ind Eng. 2018;124:304-315. doi:1016/j.cie.2018.06.016
  73. Liu Z, Rexachs D, Epelde F, Luque E. An agent-based model for quantitatively analyzing and predicting the complex behavior of emergency departments. J Comput Sci. 2017;21:11-23. doi:1016/j.jocs.2017.05.015

Articles in Press, Corrected Proof
Available Online from 01 June 2022
  • Receive Date: 24 August 2021
  • Revise Date: 20 May 2022
  • Accept Date: 01 June 2022
  • First Publish Date: 01 June 2022